Find and Book Top Rated Hotels in New Buffalo

Search among 5 available hotels and places to stay in New Buffalo from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
Filter & Sort
View map
1-5 out of 5
Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.0
Great62 reviews
MapView on map1.9 km from City Centre1.9 km from New Buffalo Parks Dept
From   US$ 74 /nightSelect
8.4
Great79 reviews
MapView on map2.1 km from City Centre1.9 km from Four Winds Casino
From   US$ 84 /nightSelect
2.1 km from City Centre2.1 km from Four Winds Casino
From   US$ 277 /nightSelect
8.2
Great15 reviews
400 m from City Centre600 m from New Buffalo Parks Dept
From   US$ 205 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good6 reviews
5.5 km from City Centre
From   US$ 393 /nightSelect

Best hotels and places to stay in New Buffalo

Why visit?

New Buffalo, Michigan, is an attractive tourist destination for both relaxation and outdoor activities. With its stunning beaches, charming downtown area, and proximity to local wineries, it offers a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of city life. Whether youre looking for a cozy beachside hotel or a luxurious resort, New Buffalo has a variety of accommodations to suit every travelers needs.

Where to stay?

Downtown New Buffalo: The heart of the town, Downtown New Buffalo, is a vibrant and bustling area that offers a mix of boutique hotels, charming inns, and bed and breakfast establishments. Staying here puts you within walking distance of the towns best restaurants, shops, and galleries. Youll also have easy access to the beautiful beaches along Lake Michigan, making it a great choice for those seeking convenience and a lively atmosphere.

New Buffalo Beach: For a beachfront experience, staying in a hotel along New Buffalo Beach is a wonderful option. Wake up to breathtaking views of Lake Michigan and enjoy direct access to the sandy shores. From here, you can spend your days lounging on the beach, swimming in the crystal-clear waters, or indulging in various water sports. The area offers a range of beachfront hotels and resorts, giving you the ultimate beach getaway.

Harbor Country: Just a short drive from downtown, Harbor Country is a picturesque region known for its scenic beauty and charming small towns. Staying in this area allows you to explore quaint shops, dine at local eateries, and visit unique art galleries. With its tranquil ambiance and proximity to wineries, Harbor Country is an ideal choice for those looking to relax and immerse themselves in the beauty of nature.

What is the price per hotel room per night?

3-star hotels: The average price per night is around $100 to $150.

4-star hotels: The average price per night is around $150 to $250.

5-star hotels: The average price per night is around $250 to $400.

Best value for money:

Comfort Inn New Buffalo: Located conveniently near downtown New Buffalo, this hotel offers comfortable rooms at an affordable price. With amenities such as complimentary breakfast, an indoor pool, and free Wi-Fi, it provides great value for your money. The hotels central location allows easy access to local attractions, including the beach and restaurants.

Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo: Situated just minutes away from Lake Michigan, this hotel offers modern and spacious rooms. The property features a fitness center, indoor pool, and complimentary breakfast. With its competitive rates and excellent amenities, it is a great choice for budget-conscious travelers looking for a comfortable stay.

Baymont by Wyndham New Buffalo: Offering a blend of affordability and convenience, this hotel provides clean and comfortable rooms. Guests can enjoy amenities like a complimentary breakfast, free Wi-Fi, and a fitness center. Its location near the interstate makes it convenient for exploring the nearby attractions, including the Four Winds Casino.

Best kid-friendly hotels:

New Buffalo Inn & Spa: This family-friendly hotel features spacious rooms and suites, some with separate living areas. Kids will love the indoor pool, while parents can relax at the spa. The hotels location near the beach provides opportunities for fun-filled beach activities and building sandcastles.

The Harbor Grand: This luxurious waterfront hotel offers a range of family-friendly amenities, including a kids play area and complimentary bicycles to explore the area. With spacious rooms and suites, some with lake views, it provides a comfortable and enjoyable stay for the whole family.

Best hotels for a romantic getaway:

Marina Grand Resort: Nestled along the New Buffalo Harbor, this upscale resort offers expansive views of Lake Michigan. Couples can enjoy private balconies, a marina with boat rentals, and an on-site spa. With its scenic location and luxurious accommodations, it sets the perfect ambiance for a romantic escape.

The Inn at Harbor Shores: This elegant hotel boasts stylish rooms with plush furnishings and lake views. It offers a variety of romantic packages, including wine tastings and couples spa treatments. With its waterfront location and proximity to local wineries, it is an ideal choice for a romantic getaway.

Best for location:

Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo: This hotel is conveniently located near Lake Michigan, offering easy access to the beach. It is also close to entertainment options such as the Four Winds Casino and the New Buffalo Public Library.

The Harbor Grand: Situated in the heart of downtown New Buffalo, this hotel is within walking distance of the towns best attractions, including shops, restaurants, and galleries. Its prime location also provides access to the beach and local marinas.

Comfort Inn New Buffalo: This hotel is centrally located, offering convenient access to downtown New Buffalo, the beach, and nearby attractions. Guests can easily explore the town and enjoy various recreational activities.

Best for a short city break:

Marina Grand Resort: With its luxurious amenities, beautiful lake views, and proximity to downtown New Buffalo, this resort makes for an indulgent and rejuvenating city break. Guests can enjoy the resorts spa, on-site dining options, and entertainment venues nearby.

The Inn at Harbor Shores: This upscale hotel offers a serene retreat with its modern rooms and lake views. Its location near Harbor Shores Golf Club and downtown attractions makes it a great choice for a short getaway filled with golfing, shopping, and relaxation.

Show moreLess