Top Hotels in Sag Harbor

Search among 2 available hotels and places to stay in Sag Harbor from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
1-2 out of 2
1Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Places to stay near Sag Harbor
8.4
Great33 reviews
MapView on map12.6 km from Sag Harbor12.6 km from City Centre
From   US$ 1 015 /nightSelect
8.2
Great43 reviews
MapView on map11.4 km from Sag Harbor11.4 km from City Centre
From   US$ 283 /nightSelect

Best Hotels and Places to Stay in Sag Harbor

Why visit?

Sag Harbor, located in the United States, offers a charming and picturesque escape for tourists. With its rich history, beautiful landscapes, and vibrant culture, Sag Harbor provides an ideal destination for those seeking a unique and relaxing getaway. Sag Harbor hotels offer a range of accommodations, from luxurious resorts to cozy lodges, ensuring that every visitor finds the perfect place to stay.

Where to stay?

Downtown Sag Harbor: This bustling area is perfect for tourists who want to be in the heart of the action. With a variety of shops, restaurants, and art galleries, Downtown Sag Harbor offers a lively atmosphere to explore. There are several hotels and resorts in the vicinity, providing convenient access to the towns attractions. Whether you prefer a boutique hotel or a charming bed and breakfast, there are plenty of options to choose from.

Waterfront Area: For those who want to experience the tranquil beauty of Sag Harbor, staying in the waterfront area is a great choice. Overlooking the harbor, this area offers breathtaking views and easy access to beaches and water activities. Whether you choose a waterfront resort or a cozy inn, youll enjoy a serene and peaceful atmosphere. Many hotels in this area provide amenities such as private docks and outdoor seating areas, allowing visitors to fully embrace the coastal lifestyle.

Historic District: If youre interested in immersing yourself in Sag Harbors rich history, staying in the Historic District is a must. This area is home to beautifully preserved buildings dating back to the 18th and 19th centuries. You can find charming bed and breakfasts and boutique hotels that capture the essence of Sag Harbors past. With the towns museums, art galleries, and historic landmarks just steps away, the Historic District offers a truly unique and immersive experience.

What is the price per hotel room per night?

3-star hotels: The average price per night is around $200 to $300.

4-star hotels: The average price per night is around $300 to $500.

5-star hotels: The average price per night is around $500 to $1000.

Best Value for Money:

The Forever Breeze Inn: This charming inn offers affordable rates without compromising on comfort. Located in the heart of Sag Harbor, it provides easy access to the towns attractions, making it a great choice for budget-conscious travelers. The cozy rooms are equipped with all the necessary amenities, and the friendly staff ensures a pleasant stay.

The Sag Harbor Inn: Situated right on the waterfront, this inn offers stunning views and a convenient location. The rooms are tastefully decorated and feature modern amenities. With its reasonable rates and proximity to Sag Harbors main attractions, this hotel provides excellent value for money.

The Sag Harbor House: This well-maintained hotel offers comfortable accommodations at affordable prices. The rooms are spacious and equipped with modern amenities, providing a pleasant stay for guests. Its central location allows visitors to explore Sag Harbors shops, restaurants, and beaches with ease.

Best Kids-Friendly Hotels:

Barons Cove: This family-friendly resort offers a range of amenities and activities for children, including a kids club, outdoor pool, and game room. The spacious rooms provide plenty of space for families to relax and unwind. Its pet-friendly policy ensures that the whole family can enjoy a memorable stay in Sag Harbor.

The American Hotel: With its historic charm and elegant atmosphere, this hotel welcomes families with open arms. The spacious suites provide ample space for parents and children, and the attentive staff is always ready to cater to their needs. Its convenient location allows easy access to Sag Harbors attractions and family-friendly restaurants.

Best Hotels for Romantic Getaway:

The Topping Rose House: This luxurious resort offers a perfect setting for a romantic escape. Set amidst beautifully landscaped gardens, it provides a tranquil and intimate atmosphere. The spacious rooms are elegantly decorated, featuring modern amenities and breathtaking views. Couples can indulge in spa treatments or savor gourmet meals at the on-site restaurant.

The Watchcase Inn: Nestled in the heart of the Historic District, this boutique hotel exudes charm and romance. The beautifully designed rooms and suites are equipped with luxurious amenities, ensuring a comfortable and intimate stay. Couples can enjoy leisurely walks along the waterfront or explore Sag Harbors quaint streets hand-in-hand.

Best for Location:

The Sag Harbor Hotel: Located right on the waterfront, this hotel offers stunning views of the harbor. Guests can easily access the towns shops, restaurants, and attractions, making it a convenient choice for exploring Sag Harbor. The cozy rooms and friendly service make for a delightful stay.

The Sag Harbor Inn & Suites: Situated in the heart of Downtown Sag Harbor, this hotel provides easy access to the towns popular landmarks and vibrant dining scene. The spacious suites offer a comfortable retreat after a day of exploring, and the attentive staff ensures a memorable experience for guests.

The Harbor House Inn: This charming inn is located just steps away from Sag Harbors marinas and beaches. Guests can enjoy the convenience of being close to the water activities while also being within walking distance of downtown attractions. The cozy rooms and warm hospitality make it a great choice for enjoying the best of Sag Harbors location.

Best for a Short City Break:

The Sag Harbor House Retreat: This boutique hotel offers a serene and secluded setting for a quick getaway. Surrounded by lush gardens, it provides a peaceful atmosphere to relax and recharge. The well-appointed rooms and personalized service ensure a comfortable stay.

The Forever Inn Retreat: Situated in a quiet area, this inn offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle. The cozy rooms provide a comfortable retreat, and the peaceful outdoor spaces are perfect for unwinding. With easy access to Sag Harbors attractions, this hotel is ideal for a relaxing city break.

Show moreLess