We had a fabulous stay at an enchanting castle nestled in a serene location. The surroundings were breathtaking, with lush fields perfect for morning strolls. The atmosphere of the castle itself was truly captivating, transporting us back in time. Our room exceeded expectations, boasting a beautifully handcrafted four-poster bed that added a touch of luxury to our stay. The meals served were delectable, and we were particularly impressed with the slow-cooked lamb and the mouthwatering upside-down cheesecake. But what truly made our stay unforgettable was the amazing staff. They went above and beyond to ensure we had a memorable experience, engaging us with their delightful banter and making us feel incredibly welcome. Despite minor flaws like dated bathroom fixtures and the absence of some amenities, we would wholeheartedly recommend this extraordinary hotel. we had a fantastic time and would definitely return in the future.

The complimentary mulled wine and mince pies were a nice touch during the Christmas holiday. The hotel location is perfect for those who want to be surrounded by nature and have some quiet time. The snow-covered landscape made the scenery even more beautiful.

The heating in the room was inadequate and the bathroom was freezing cold. The hot water in the shower didn't last long enough for a comfortable shower.

Beautiful grounds, clean rooms with charming antiques. Friendly staff and stunning breakfast.

The Melville Castle Hotel offers a stunning location with beautiful grounds, perfect for weddings and photographs. The hotel has a charming old-school decor, with statues and ornaments that give it an authentic castle feel. The rooms are comfortable, with a lovely bed and nice amenities such as a full-length mirror and tea/coffee facilities. Staff in the bars and marquee are friendly and attentive, providing excellent service.

The dinner service at the hotel was below par, with mistakes on the bill and delays in getting drinks and food. The lack of dining management and overwhelmed staff detracted from the overall experience.

The location of the hotel is great for nature lovers as it is surrounded by beautiful grounds, perfect for a leisurely stroll. You can even find historic trees planted by Mary Queen of Scots and her secretary David Rizzio down the lane. The room itself was spacious, with a unique layout featuring a mezzanine level for the bedroom area. The staff were polite and helpful, ensuring a pleasant stay. The breakfast buffet offered a reasonable variety of options.

The restaurant in the hotel provided small portions at a high cost and had a limited menu.

I had a fantastic stay at this beautiful castle in Dalkeith. The hotel facilities were top-notch, with a fantastic bar offering a wide selection of drinks. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful, and they immediately assisted me with my luggage upon arrival. The location was perfect for me, as it was close enough to easily taxi to Edinburgh center for work. Additionally, the breakfast provided was delicious and offered both continental and a full Scottish breakfast. The cleanliness of the hotel was impeccable, and the attention to detail in the large room was impressive.

Nothing negative to say.

We loved our stay at the castle. The rooms were spacious and comfortable, and there were beautiful trails to explore. The hotel provided delicious meals and had a well-stocked bar. We would definitely stay here again!

We felt happy with our stay and had no reason to complain.

Beautiful grounds. Clean rooms with lovely antiques. Friendly staff. Spectacular breakfast. Breathtaking location. Great history. Attentive and helpful staff. Peaceful night sleep.

Didn't dislike anything about the property.

I recently stayed at this wonderful venue for a few nights and had a great experience. The location was perfect for me as it was close to the area I needed to be in for work. I also enjoyed the quirky restaurant in the castle for a few drinks to wind down. The staff were simply amazing, from receptionists to waiters, and went above and beyond their service. I appreciated their warm welcome and the welcome drink was a nice touch. The room was well-equipped with modern amenities such as flat-screen TV, electric kettle and am/fm alarm clock. Above all, the leisure garden area was a perfect place to relax and unwind.

This hotel is a perfect family-friendly place with board games, children's menu and pets allowed.

We had a fantastic stay here! The grounds were absolutely beautiful and peaceful, perfect for a relaxing getaway. Our room was cozy and impeccably decorated, with a lovely view of the horses. The entire castle was stunning and comfortable, and the food in the restaurant was delicious. The staff went above and beyond to make sure we had a wonderful time, offering great advice and always making us feel welcome. The breakfast was exceptional as well!

Great place for families!

Our stay at Melville Castle was truly unforgettable. The castle's secluded location ensured a peaceful and noise-free atmosphere, perfect for exploring the grounds. The blend of traditional castle elements and modern interior design was impressive, especially the library area with its full bar and cozy fireplace. The 24-hour reception kept us in constant communication, and the staff's cleanliness and professionalism were commendable. Special mention goes to the chef for the delicious food. We cannot wait to visit again and experience the tranquility and elegance of Melville Castle.

We had a lovely stay at a castle just outside Edinburgh. The location is picturesque, with beautiful fields for morning walks. Our room was beautifully furnished, with a four poster bed and a great view of the gardens. The service was friendly and efficient, and the food at the restaurant was hot, well-prepared, and tasty. The breakfast had plenty of choice and was warm and delicious. a fantastic setting for a memorable stay.

The restaurant had an inadequate number of staff, leading to delays in ordering and receiving our meal.

We had a great value for our money at Melville Castle. The room was lovely and the hotel amenities were nice. The location was beautiful and we enjoyed walking our dog in the surrounding areas. The staff were friendly and accommodating.

More breakfast choices would have made our stay even better.

I recently stayed at Melville Castle for a weekend getaway. The gothic decor inside the stunning building was absolutely astonishing. The bedrooms were clean, comfortable, and full of character. The staff, especially the friendly Spanish Lady and reception staff, were attentive and helpful. The attention to detail in the delicious dinner and stylish decor in the dining room and our room were impressive. The location, with its breathtaking surroundings and peaceful atmosphere, was perfect for a relaxing break. I would definitely recommend this place for a unique and enjoyable stay.

Strongly recommend this hotel.

The hotel is set in beautiful grounds with walking trails, creating a peaceful and relaxing atmosphere. the location was convenient, being only a short drive away from the center of the city.

The room we stayed in had a few issues, such as a broken blind in the shower room and a poorly lit tea making area, which posed a safety risk. The temperature in the hotel was also quite cold, with only the main reception fire working.