I had an amazing stay at this hotel. The beds and pillows were incredibly comfortable, giving me the best night's sleep. The staff was friendly and accommodating, even cleaning our room early so we could check in before heading to Put In Bay. The hotel's location was perfect, just a short walk to the Jet Express, making transportation super convenient.

Nothing, all aspects of this hotel were excellent.

Enjoyed the history and charm of the vintage building located near Lake Erie. Great breakfast in the morning before some nearby shopping and food spots. Comfortable bed and overall clean atmosphere. Helpful and friendly staff added to the pleasant stay. Quiet area for a relaxing getaway.

Convenient location, friendly manager, discount offered, clean room, comfortable bed.

Nothing to dislike.

This hotel is a hidden gem by the shores of Lake Erie, offering great value for money. The rooms, some with tall windows overlooking the lake, are updated and clean, with attention to detail. The friendly staff and convenient location near everything we wanted made our stay enjoyable. The comfortable King size bed ensured a good night's sleep.

Minor improvements can be made in terms of breakfast options, as on Monday there were no hot foods available. It would have been nice for the hotel to offer a hot meal for late risers.

Staying here was a great experience! The location was perfect for me, as I was able to walk to the ferry to Put-in-Bay and there were many restaurants nearby. The service was fantastic and the room was very relaxing with all the amenities I needed. I especially appreciated the comfortable bed and the ironing facilities. The garden furniture outside was a nice touch, and I enjoyed having tea and coffee in the sitting area of my room.

I’d highly recommend this place to everyone.

I stayed at Island House for a weekend trip and had a wonderful time. The hotel's historic charm added a unique touch to my stay. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful, making me feel welcomed throughout my visit. The room, though small, had everything I needed and the large bathroom was a pleasant surprise. The hotel was clean and comfortable, and the bed provided a great night's sleep. The location was perfect, with everything I needed within walking distance, including the ferry port to Put-in-Bay. I definitely plan on staying here again in the future.

I recommend this hotel.

This hotel on the shores of Lake Erie is a great value for the price. The staff are friendly and attentive. The rooms are well-appointed, with a small refrigerator beside the bed, and there are plenty of amenities nearby.

All was just fine, no complaints.

During our stay at The Island House, we were captivated by its rich history. The high ceilings and tall windows in our room provided a breathtaking view of the serene lake. We loved the authentic charm of the hardwood bones, a true embodiment of a memorable travel accommodation. The location was ideal, allowing us to enjoy the beauty of the surroundings. The staff was friendly and made us feel welcome throughout our stay.

The bed and pillows were amazing, giving me the best night's sleep. The location of the hotel was perfect, with restaurants, shops, marinas, and bars all within close proximity. Moreover, the hot water in the shower was plentiful, allowing for a comfortable and refreshing start to the day.

The common areas of the hotel were in need of some freshening up. The odor emanating from the sports bar detracted from the overall historic vibe of the building.

I was amazed by the convenient access to the Jet Express from The Island House. It made our day trips to Put in Bay so easy and enjoyable. I had a great experience and would recommend this hotel.

I had a really nice surprise during my stay at this hotel. the location is excellent if you enjoy the charm of a small town and walking accessibility. It's within walking distance to the Jet Express, bars, restaurants, and other tourist attractions. Secondly, the staff was very friendly and accommodating, making sure all our needs were met. And finally, the value for money was great, with affordable prices for a comfortable stay. I was pleasantly surprised by this hotel and would definitely stay here again.

All was fine, no complaints.

If you want to experience a spooky hotel that looks like it's from a horror movie, this is your spot, but beware of the hotel's dated appearance. The best advantage is that it is in a location that's a stone's throw away from the ferry to Put-in-Bay, and you can quickly hop on and off the island. Also, the lounge area has entertainment that can be a good option to pass time.

There is an aggressive policy related to smoking inside the hotel, and even sneaking weed is severely punished.

Small but adequate rooms, historic charm, cleanest room/facility, convenient location within walking distance to attractions.

Felt very well looked after, nothing too much trouble.

Neat historic spot, friendly staff, and great rates. Spacious and clean rooms with plenty of amenities and things to do. Complimentary breakfast was excellent. Recommended for anyone looking to stay in the area! 👍

Informative staff. Historical feel. Well-maintained. Great dining atmosphere. Accommodating to OSU Marching Band.

Nothing, all was good.