Find and Book Top Hotels in Bay Shore

Search among 18 available hotels and places to stay in Bay Shore from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
Filter & Sort
View map
1-18 out of 18
Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.6
Great18 reviews
MapView on map1100 yd from City Center1200 yd from Saint Georges University School
From   US$ 540 /nightSelect
MapView on map3.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 177 /nightSelect
Places to stay near Bay Shore
8.2
Great109 reviews
7.2 mi from Bay Shore7.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 109 /nightSelect
8.4
Great103 reviews
6.2 mi from Bay Shore6.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 144 /nightSelect
5.8 mi from Bay Shore5.8 mi from City Center
From   US$ 109 /nightSelect
8.2
Great108 reviews
7.2 mi from Bay Shore7.2 mi from City Center
From   US$ 179 /nightSelect
8.2
Great48 reviews
9.6 mi from Bay Shore9.6 mi from City Center
From   US$ 124 /nightSelect
13.7 mi from Bay Shore13.7 mi from City Center
From   US$ 140 /nightSelect
8.2
Great36 reviews
11.7 mi from Bay Shore11.7 mi from City Center
From   US$ 127 /nightSelect
8.4
Great16 reviews
10.8 mi from Bay Shore10.8 mi from City Center
From   US$ 99 /nightSelect
8.4
Great32 reviews
9.6 mi from Bay Shore9.6 mi from City Center
From   US$ 341 /nightSelect
8.4
Great126 reviews
6.5 mi from Bay Shore6.5 mi from City Center
From   US$ 188 /nightSelect
8.2
Great66 reviews
7.7 mi from Bay Shore7.7 mi from City Center
From   US$ 149 /nightSelect
8.0
Great11 reviews
9.3 mi from Bay Shore9.3 mi from City Center
From   US$ 149 /nightSelect
3.8 mi from Bay Shore3.8 mi from City Center
From   US$ 189 /nightSelect
8.4
Great61 reviews
6.9 mi from Bay Shore6.9 mi from City Center
From   US$ 155 /nightSelect
3.9 mi from Bay Shore3.9 mi from City Center
From   US$ 155 /nightSelect
8.4
Great10 reviews
7.0 mi from Bay Shore7.0 mi from City Center
From   US$ 299 /nightSelect

Best Hotels and Places to Stay in Bay Shore

Why Visit?

Bay Shore, located in the United States, is a charming coastal town that offers a perfect blend of natural beauty, cultural attractions, and a vibrant dining scene. With its beautiful beaches, quaint downtown area, and proximity to popular destinations like Fire Island, Bay Shore is an ideal choice for travelers seeking a relaxing and enjoyable vacation.

Where to Stay?

Bay Shore offers several great areas to stay, each with its own unique charm and appeal. Consider these top areas when choosing your hotel in Bay Shore:

Downtown Bay Shore: This vibrant area is filled with shops, restaurants, and entertainment venues, making it a great choice for those who want easy access to local attractions.

South Shore: Situated close to the beach, this area offers stunning ocean views and a tranquil atmosphere perfect for a seaside getaway.

West Bay Shore: Surrounded by lush greenery and picturesque landscapes, West Bay Shore is an ideal option for nature lovers and those seeking a peaceful retreat.

Price per Hotel Room per Night

In Bay Shore, the average price per night varies across different hotel categories. Here is a rough estimate of the average prices:

3-star hotels: $120-$150 per night

4-star hotels: $180-$220 per night

5-star hotels: $250-$350 per night

Best Value for Money

Bay Shore Inn: Offering comfortable rooms and excellent amenities at an affordable price, this hotel is a great choice for budget-conscious travelers.

The Gulf Bay Club: Known for its impeccable service and reasonable rates, this hotel provides a pleasant stay with great value for your money.

Holiday Inn Express Bay Shore: With its convenient location, complimentary breakfast, and comfortable rooms, this hotel offers excellent value for families or business travelers.

Best Kids-Friendly Hotels

Courtyard by Marriott Long Island: This family-friendly hotel features spacious rooms, an indoor pool, and a variety of kid-friendly amenities for a memorable stay.

Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island: Offering fully equipped suites and a range of activities for children, this hotel ensures a delightful experience for the whole family.

Best Hotels for a Romantic Getaway

Ocean Bay House: Nestled close to the shoreline, this bed and breakfast offers a romantic ambiance, breathtaking views, and elegant rooms for a memorable couples' retreat.

The Wilson House: With its charming decor, cozy atmosphere, and personalized service, this boutique hotel provides the perfect setting for a romantic escape.

Best for Location

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport: Situated near the airport and major highways, this hotel provides a central location for travelers to explore Bay Shore and beyond.

Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex: Located near historic sites and shopping areas, this hotel offers a fantastic location for both leisure and business travelers.

Best for a Short City Break

Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia: Featuring modern amenities, comfortable rooms, and a complimentary breakfast, this hotel is perfect for a quick, hassle-free city break.

Marriott Melville: With its close proximity to attractions like Adventureland and Walt Whitman Birthplace, this hotel offers a convenient base for a short getaway.

In conclusion, Bay Shore offers a range of accommodation options that cater to different preferences and budgets. Whether you're looking for value for money, a family-friendly hotel, a romantic retreat, a central location, or a short city break, Bay Shore has something for everyone.

Note: The mentioned prices are approximate and may vary based on factors such as seasonality and availability. It is recommended to check with each hotel directly for the most accurate pricing information.

Show moreLess