Find and Book Top Rated Hotels in New Shoreham

Search among 12 available hotels and places to stay in New Shoreham from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
Filter & Sort
View map
1-12 out of 12
Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.6
Great39 reviews
MapView on map400 yd from City Center300 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 827 /nightSelect
8.0
Great7 reviews
MapView on map600 yd from City Center500 yd from Greenway Walking Trails
From   US$ 1 008 /nightSelect
8.6
Great1 review
600 yd from City Center600 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 350 /nightSelect
7.6
Very good20 reviews
1.0 mi from City Center1600 yd from Block Island Historical Society
From   US$ 489 /nightSelect
8.4
Great40 reviews
200 yd from City Center200 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 349 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
8.2
Great28 reviews
700 yd from City Center500 yd from Greenway Walking Trails
From   US$ 459 /nightSelect
8.0
Great1 review
1400 yd from City Center800 yd from Block Island Historical Society
From   US$ 339 /nightSelect
Hotel
8.4
Great23 reviews
1.0 mi from City Center700 yd from Block Island Historical Society
From   US$ 155 /nightSelect
600 yd from City Center600 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 562 /nightSelect
100 yd from City Center100 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 649 /nightSelect
1100 yd from City Center400 yd from Block Island Historical Society
From   US$ 174 /nightSelect
300 yd from City Center300 yd from Old Harbor Historic District
From   US$ 630 /nightSelect

Best hotels and places to stay in New Shoreham

Why visit?

New Shoreham, located on Block Island in the United States, is a charming destination that offers a unique island experience. With its beautiful beaches, picturesque landscapes, historic sites, and vibrant community, it is an ideal place for a relaxing vacation or an adventurous getaway.

Where to stay?

When it comes to choosing the best areas in New Shoreham to stay, the following neighborhoods offer a range of accommodations to suit different preferences and budgets:

Old Harbor: This bustling area is the main port and commercial center of Block Island. Staying here allows easy access to popular attractions, restaurants, and shops.

Crescent Beach/Mohegan Bluffs: For travelers seeking a tranquil beachside retreat, this area offers stunning ocean views and a serene ambiance.

New Harbor: Located on the west side of the island, New Harbor boasts a quieter atmosphere and is a great choice for those looking to escape the crowds and enjoy the island's natural beauty.

Price per hotel room per night:

On average, prices for hotel rooms per night in New Shoreham vary according to the hotel's star rating. Please note that prices may vary depending on the season and availability.

3-star hotels: Prices range from $150 to $250 per night.

4-star hotels: Prices range from $250 to $400 per night.

5-star hotels: Prices range from $400 and above per night.

Best value for money:

The National Hotel: This historic hotel offers comfortable rooms and excellent amenities at a reasonable price. Its central location in Old Harbor makes it convenient for exploring the island. Prices start at $170 per night.

Block Island Beach House: Known for its friendly staff and relaxing atmosphere, this hotel provides comfortable accommodations with direct access to the beach. Prices start at $220 per night.

The Inn at Old Harbor: This cozy inn offers clean and comfortable rooms with complimentary breakfast. Its location in Old Harbor provides easy access to shops and restaurants. Prices start at $180 per night.

Best kid-friendly hotels:

Spring House Hotel: This family-friendly hotel features spacious rooms and a range of activities for children, including a kids' club and a playground. Prices start at $270 per night.

Avonlea Coastal Farmhouse: Located near the beach, this charming farmhouse offers a welcoming atmosphere and spacious accommodations suitable for families with children. Prices start at $250 per night.

Best hotels for a romantic getaway:

The Sullivan House: This waterfront hotel provides a romantic setting with breathtaking ocean views and a private beach. Couples can enjoy a peaceful and intimate stay. Prices start at $380 per night.

The 1661 Inn: Nestled in a scenic location, this inn offers cozy rooms and a charming ambiance, perfect for couples seeking a romantic escape. Prices start at $350 per night.

Best for location:

The Bellevue House: Situated in Old Harbor, this hotel offers convenient access to shops, restaurants, and the ferry dock. Guests can easily explore the island from this central location. Prices start at $190 per night.

Ballard's Beach Resort: Located right on the beach, this resort allows guests to enjoy the sand and surf just steps away from their rooms. It's also close to the popular bars and restaurants in Old Harbor. Prices start at $330 per night.

The Gothic Inn: Overlooking the scenic Old Harbor, this inn offers stunning views and a peaceful atmosphere. It is within walking distance of many attractions and dining options. Prices start at $220 per night.

Best for a short city break:

Hotel Manisses: This boutique hotel offers a cozy and relaxing environment, allowing guests to unwind and enjoy the island's tranquility. Prices start at $240 per night.

Blue Dory Inn: With its beachfront location, this inn provides a laid-back atmosphere and comfortable accommodations for a refreshing city break experience. Prices start at $220 per night.

Show moreLess