Top Hotels in Sister Bay

Search among 6 available hotels and places to stay in Sister Bay from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
1Filter & Sort
View map
1-6 out of 6
1Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.2
Great55 reviews
MapView on map1.2 mi from City Center1100 yd from Sister Bay Historical
From   US$ 96 /nightSelect
8.4
Great71 reviews
MapView on map900 yd from City Center600 yd from Sister Bay Historical
From   US$ 190 /nightSelect
8.6
Great41 reviews
600 yd from City Center1100 yd from Family Artist
From   US$ 204 /nightSelect
8.2
Great45 reviews
900 yd from City Center700 yd from Family Artist
From   US$ 218 /nightSelect
8.6
Great39 reviews
1200 yd from City Center200 yd from Sister Bay Historical
From   US$ 102 /nightSelect
8.4
Great53 reviews
1.4 mi from City Center1500 yd from Sister Bay Historical
From   US$ 229 /nightSelect

Best hotels and places to stay in Sister Bay

Why visit?

Sister Bay in Wisconsin is a charming destination for tourists seeking a serene getaway. With its picturesque waterfront, cozy accommodations, and a variety of outdoor activities, Sister Bay offers a perfect blend of relaxation and adventure. Whether you are looking for a sister bay hotel, resort, or lodging, this small town has plenty to offer, making it an ideal choice for a memorable vacation.

Where to stay?

Downtown Sister Bay: Stay in the heart of the towns vibrant atmosphere by choosing a hotel or resort in downtown Sister Bay. Enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, and attractions. Walking along the scenic waterfront, youll find numerous hotels in Sister Bay that cater to different budgets and preferences. From boutique hotels to well-known chains, downtown Sister Bay offers diverse options for a comfortable stay.

Beachfront Resorts: For those seeking a relaxing beach vacation, considering a resort in Sister Bay with direct access to the beautiful shoreline is a great choice. Wake up to breathtaking views of Lake Michigan and unwind by spending lazy afternoons on the sandy beaches. Many waterfront resorts in Sister Bay offer amenities such as pools, spa services, and outdoor activities, ensuring a memorable stay for guests.

Countryside Charm: If you prefer a more tranquil setting, look for lodging options outside the heart of Sister Bay. Tucked away in the scenic countryside, these accommodations offer a peaceful atmosphere amidst natures beauty. From cozy bed and breakfasts to charming cabins, the countryside hotels in Sister Bay provide an opportunity to relax and rejuvenate away from the crowds.

What is the price per hotel room per night?

3-star hotels: The average price per night is around $100 to $200.

4-star hotels: The average price per night is around $200 to $300.

5-star hotels: The average price per night is around $300 to $500.

Best value for money:

Sister Bay Hotel & Resort: This hotel offers a great combination of affordability and comfort. Located in downtown Sister Bay, it provides easy access to local attractions and amenities. The rooms are clean and well-appointed, and the friendly staff ensures a pleasant stay. With reasonable rates and convenient location, Sister Bay Hotel & Resort is an excellent choice for travelers on a budget.

The Lodge at Leathem Smith: Situated near the waterfront, this charming lodge offers comfortable accommodations at a reasonable price. The rooms are spacious and tastefully decorated, providing a cozy atmosphere for guests. The lodge features an on-site restaurant and bar, allowing visitors to unwind and enjoy delicious meals without leaving the premises. With its affordable rates and waterfront location, The Lodge at Leathem Smith offers excellent value for money.

Country House Resort: Nestled in the countryside, this resort provides a serene and peaceful stay for a reasonable price. Surrounded by lush greenery, it offers breathtaking views of the bay and easy access to outdoor activities. The rooms are comfortable and well-maintained, and the resort features amenities such as a heated pool and hiking trails. Country House Resort is a great choice for those seeking a tranquil getaway without breaking the bank.

Best kids-friendly hotels:

Scandia Cottages: These cozy cottages cater to families with children, providing a comfortable and kid-friendly environment. The cottages are spacious and equipped with all the necessary amenities, including kitchenettes for convenient meal preparation. The property features a playground and picnic areas, ensuring plenty of entertainment options for the little ones. Scandia Cottages offer a home-away-from-home experience for families visiting Sister Bay.

Birchwood Lodge: This family-friendly hotel offers spacious suites that provide ample space for both parents and kids. The suites feature separate bedrooms and living areas, allowing for privacy and relaxation. The hotel has a heated swimming pool, game room, and outdoor areas for children to play. With its family-oriented amenities and convenient location, Birchwood Lodge is an excellent choice for a memorable family vacation.

Best hotels for a romantic getaway:

The Inn at Little Sister Hill: This cozy inn provides a romantic retreat for couples seeking a quiet and intimate atmosphere. The suites are beautifully decorated and equipped with fireplaces and whirlpool tubs, creating a romantic ambiance. The inn is surrounded by nature, offering stunning views and easy access to hiking trails. With its peaceful setting and romantic features, The Inn at Little Sister Hill is perfect for couples looking to reconnect.

Eagle Harbor Inn: Situated in a secluded area, this charming inn offers a romantic and peaceful escape. The rooms are elegantly appointed, featuring luxurious amenities like private balconies and soaking tubs. The inn provides a complimentary gourmet breakfast every morning, and its location allows for easy access to nearby attractions. Couples can enjoy a serene and intimate getaway at Eagle Harbor Inn.

Best for location:

Waterfront Village Condominiums: Located in the heart of Sister Bay, these condominiums offer stunning waterfront views and proximity to local shops and restaurants. The units are spacious, well-maintained, and equipped with modern amenities. Guests can enjoy direct access to the waterfront, perfect for leisurely strolls or water activities. Waterfront Village Condominiums provide an ideal location for exploring the towns attractions.

The Inn at Cedar Crossing: Situated in downtown Sister Bay, this historic inn provides easy access to the towns popular destinations. The inn features charming rooms with antique decor and modern comforts. Guests can savor delicious meals at the on-site farm-to-table restaurant or explore the nearby shops and galleries. The convenient location of The Inn at Cedar Crossing makes it a great choice for those wanting to immerse themselves in the towns vibrant atmosphere.

Open Hearth Lodge: Located just outside of Sister Bay, this lodge offers a tranquil setting while still being within close proximity to the towns attractions. Nestled amidst nature, it provides a peaceful retreat surrounded by beautiful landscapes. The lodge offers spacious rooms and amenities such as an outdoor pool and picnic areas. Open Hearth Lodge provides a convenient yet peaceful location for a memorable stay.

Best for a short city break:

Liberty Lodge: Situated in downtown Sister Bay, this lodge offers a convenient location for a short city break. The rooms are comfortable and well-maintained, providing a cozy atmosphere for guests. The lodge has a relaxing outdoor patio and is within walking distance of various shops and restaurants. Liberty Lodge is perfect for those looking for a quick and enjoyable getaway.

Scandinavian Lodge: Set in a serene location just a short drive from Sister Bay, this lodge provides a peaceful escape from the city. The spacious suites are tastefully decorated and offer modern amenities, including kitchens and whirlpool tubs. The lodge features an indoor and outdoor pool, fitness center, and picnic areas. Scandinavian Lodge offers a convenient and relaxing option for a short city break.

Show moreLess