Open Hearth Lodge, Sister Bay (WI) - Deals & Reviews

Cozy community vibes by the fireplace!

This cozy lodge offers a perfect blend of warmth and comfort. My stay featured delightful pancakes, a fantastic hot tub, and a welcoming atmosphere filled with friendly guests. The attentive staff goes the extra mile to make everyone feel at home. Don't forget to enjoy the outdoor fire pits amidst the beautiful surroundings!

Charming outdoor fire pits for relaxation.

Unfortunately, our experience was marred by several issues. The room we stayed in had an unpleasant musty smell upon check-in that was hard to overlook. Additionally, the cleanliness left much to be desired, as we found long hair on the floor right when we entered, prompting me to grab a broom myself! Lastly, the uncomfortable love seat made it difficult to relax after a long day of exploring Sister Bay.

i had a previous stay in sister bay, but this visit was something special. the atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the communal areas were perfect for relaxing with family. i loved the outdoor fire pits and enjoyed the spacious grounds for evening hangs. the pancake-maker at breakfast was a fun highlight that exceeded my expectations.

breakfast could use more fresh fruit options.

The spacious grounds, the welcoming outdoor fire pits, the friendly staff was simply delightful.

Had an incredible time at this lodge with my family and our pups. They gave us this cool doggy basket with treats and a blanket so our dogs could chill on the couch like they own the place, which they kinda do. Oh, and the staff even lit the outside firepit one night when we were there, which was perfect for roasting marshmallows and just hanging out. Everything felt super cozy and welcoming, just like home.

It wasn’t exactly cheap , but for the experience we had, I’d say it was worth it.

i had a previous stay in sister bay, but this visit was something special. the atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the communal areas were perfect for relaxing with family. everything from the cozy furnishings to the included breakfast exceeded my expectations during our group visit.

more fresh fruit options at breakfast would help.

We had a wonderful stay! The outdoor fire pits were beautifully lit each night, providing the perfect spot for family bonding. The cozy dining area and friendly staff made us feel right at home. Plus, the dogs roaming around were a delightful touch for our kids.

My kids wished for more playful outdoor activities.

Chur, the outdoor fire pits were sweet as, perfect for evening hangs! But the breakfast could've done with more fresh fruit options, felt a bit lacking. Overall, not too shabby!

The hot tub was fantastic and a great way to relax after a long day. The only downside was the limited breakfast options, especially a lack of fresh fruit. Overall, a cozy spot for families!

The inviting outdoor fire pits and spacious grounds created a perfect backdrop for family bonding. The dog wash station was a fantastic addition, making it easy for us to care for our pup after daily adventures.

The king room was so cozy with a lekker sofa and fluffy towels that felt like clouds! The brekkie was solid, loved the pancake maker—fresh pancakes in fun shapes! And the outdoor area with fire pits was perfect for chillin'.

Only bummer was no sanitizer at the tables for brekkie, could've helped.

The Superior Queen Room was comfy and cozy. The bed felt just right after a long day out. Plenty of space to chill too. The outdoor fire pits were super cool for evening hangs. The breakfast vibes were nice, but could’ve used more fresh fruit options. No hot water issues for us, which was a plus! Pretty clean overall, but some might find it a bit crowded when full. Great spot to relax, though!

open hearth lodge is a cozy spot with a great location, not far from the shops. the warm pool was super inviting, and the breakfast had a nice variety. john and jack were incredibly helpful, even opening the door for us. the outdoor firepits were perfect for relaxing.

would recommend