The value for money was great, and the room was comfortable with separate sleeping quarters, a dining table, and a desk. The location was perfect with a spectacular view of the marina, and the staff was attentive and friendly.

The food for breakfast could use some improvement.

We were blown away by the stunning views from our balcony overlooking the marina. The location was perfect, with plenty of activities within walking distance. The friendly staff made us feel so welcome, especially Jody, who provided exceptional service. The rooms were clean, well-equipped, and easily accessible. We even got a chance to glimpse the beautiful scenery from the second-story vantage point, thanks to the kind housekeeping staff. The hotel also offered happy hour specials and delicious food.

We felt so well taken care of during our stay that we have no reason to complain.

Convenient location, excellent service. Possible concerts next door. Enjoy pool and jacuzzi. Restaurant available but pricy. Spacious room with balcony and harbor view. Great stay, would come back.

Great location, friendly staff, clean rooms, comfortable stay, free morning coffee, sincere and friendly staff.

Everything great.

The view from my room at Bay Club Hotel And Marina was absolutely stunning. I had a clear sight of the beautiful bay and marinas, which made my stay truly memorable. The room was recently renovated and impeccably clean. I also enjoyed the excellent service and friendly staff at the Quarter Deck restaurant and bar. The hotel's location felt safe and the surrounding area was picturesque. despite a few minor drawbacks, I would highly recommend this hotel for a great stay.

The hotel on Shelter Island was a great find for our quick weekend trip to the city. The check-in experience was pleasant, with a friendly and helpful front desk staff. The room itself was clean, nicely appointed, and had a lovely view of the marina from the nice balcony. We appreciated the attention to detail, with amenities like a mini-fridge, coffee maker, and a safe. The location of the hotel was perfect, with plenty of nearby restaurants and a peaceful atmosphere on the island.

Our stay was enjoyable with no major issues.

Friendly Staff, Lovely Location, Beautiful View, Clean Room, Great Pool/Jacuzzi, Relaxing Atmosphere, Enjoyable Balcony, Convenient Walking Path

Nothing is perfect.

I had a pleasant stay at Bay Club Hotel And Marina. The location was ideal, allowing easy access to all the attractions in the area. The room I stayed in was clean and spacious, providing all the necessary amenities for a comfortable stay. The view of the bay was magnificent, and I enjoyed the peaceful atmosphere. The hotel staff was friendly and check-in/check-out process was smooth. The restaurant served a delicious breakfast. I would recommend this hotel for a great stay.

The location was amazing, with beautiful scenery and a convenient restaurant on site. the room was tastefully decorated and had a balcony overlooking the pool and harbor. We loved being able to dine on the patio while enjoying the view. the hotel had a refreshing pool and a small but effective fitness center. My son even had the chance to fish in the harbor, which made him very happy. it was a great experience and somewhere I would definitely book again.

The fitness center could have used some extra attention, as there were no towels or sanitizer wipes available. having my balcony door open late at night meant that we could hear noise from a nearby group, which was a bit bothersome.

I recently stayed at the Bay Club Hotel for a few days and had a wonderful experience. The staff was incredibly helpful, especially when it came to handling our luggage. The spacious room had older furniture that had been nicely updated with a fresh coat of paint. The carpet looked new and the bathroom was clean, although there was some splattered paint on the door that the maids had missed. The underground parking was convenient and easily accessible to the elevators. The location on Shelter Island provided a peaceful and quiet environment, perfect for evening walks along the waterfront. it was a pleasant stay and I would recommend this hotel.

100% Recommend this hotel.

This hotel is located in a prime spot next to the yacht club and Humphreys outdoor concerts. It is on the bay side, which offers a lovely view of the marina. The staff provide excellent service and the rooms are well decorated and comfortable, with the option for balcony seating. The pool is warm and clean, and they offer a shuttle for easy travel.

The restaurant food is hit or miss, with some dishes being great and others not so much.

My room had a stunning view of the marina and the boats. The small balcony was perfect for enjoying the scenery. The hotel's location was convenient and allowed easy access to San Diego's attractions. The bed was exceptionally comfortable and made for a great night's sleep.

I wish there was a place outside to wash the sand off our feet. I didn’t like that there wasn’t.

Our room with a balcony had a stunning water view that exceeded our expectations. Despite the rainy weather, we found the room cozy and comfortable, providing a perfect retreat. The jacuzzi was a great way to relax with an awesome view of the marina. I highly recommend this hotel.

Great service, amazing food, exceptional barman, fantastic views, perfect location, variety of restaurants nearby.

There was nothing I didn't like.

Great location, quiet at night. Good restaurants nearby. Old-fashioned bathroom fixtures, charming. Spacious ground-floor room, large terrace. Comfortable bed. Would recommend and return.