The staff at this hotel was incredibly helpful and friendly. They went above and beyond to ensure a positive welcome and provided useful recommendations for dining.

All aspects of my stay were satisfactory.

The room was clean and spacious, exceptional cleanliness, friendly and helpful staff, convenient location, close to amenities and attractions, comfortable beds.

Couldn't fault

This hotel offers great value for money, especially considering its convenient location near downtown Edgartown and many historical sites. The proximity to Stop & Shop is a bonus for those who want to do some shopping. The staff at this hotel are incredibly attentive and provide excellent service. Additionally, the rooms are well-equipped with basic amenities, including a fridge and microwave. I particularly enjoyed the comfort of the spacious room with two queen beds and the convenience of having a patio to relax on. Breakfast was also a pleasant surprise, as it was included in the stay.

Nothing to improve, everything exceeded expectations.

The staff at Edgar Hotel Martha'S Vineyard, Ascend Hotel Collection went above and beyond to ensure our stay was enjoyable. We had a small issue with our reservation, but they took care of it promptly and with a friendly attitude. They also provided great recommendations for local dining and helped us arrange transportation. Tilmon, in particular, was a standout with his excellent service and helpfulness. His dedication to providing top-notch service made us feel welcomed and valued as guests. We would definitely choose to stay at this hotel again because of the exceptional service we received.

The hotel is conveniently located near shopping areas in Edgerton, multiple historical sites, and downtown Edgartown. It is also surrounded by a variety of restaurants, making it easy to find something delicious to eat. The rooms are spacious and the bathrooms are clean and well-maintained. The staff provides excellent service and is always willing to assist. Additionally, there are facilities like a grocery store nearby, which is great for convenience.

The noise from neighboring rooms and the hallway can be quite bothersome.

Pleasant and helpful staff. Provided tote bag and beach towels. Clean and comfortable room. Convenient location near shops and restaurants. Good value for money.

We were pleasantly surprised by the cleanliness and modernity of the rooms. The recent renovation really showed in the quality of the accommodations. The location of the hotel was also a plus, as it was conveniently situated near a grocery store and the bus stop. It was only a short 10-minute walk into the charming town, making it easy to explore and enjoy the local attractions.

We had a few negative experiences during our stay. It would have been better if they had offered a more substantial breakfast or raised the room rates slightly to include a better selection.

Convenient location close to restaurants and bus stop. Spacious and clean room with nautical theme. Friendly staff allowed early check-in. Nice amenities provided. Attached restaurant had a lively atmosphere during off-season.

Helpful staff, good location, explore by foot or bus/bike, plenty of eating options, next to supermarket.

There was nothing I didn't like.

Perfect suite, modern, clean, great location, grocery store nearby.

Nothing, it is perfect.

We loved the spacious and comfortable rooms at the Edgar Hotel. The room had all the amenities we needed, including a Keurig, microwave, and refrigerator. It was great for foreign tourists like us to have these conveniences. The newly remodeled bathrooms were a nice touch too. The location was perfect, with a grocery store right next door and bike rentals across the street. It was also an easy walk to downtown. The friendly and helpful staff made our stay even better. We also appreciated the attached restaurant and bar, Town.

We felt at home at the Edgar Hotel and had no complaints whatsoever.

This hotel is a great value for money, with affordable prices for rooms that have all the basic amenities you need. The location is perfect, right next to a Stop & Shop and close to many historical sites and downtown Edgartown. I loved the rooms with 2 queen beds, fridge and microwave, and the patio was a nice touch. Plus, breakfast was included which was very convenient.

All was okay.

The hotel is conveniently located close to the center of Edgartown in Martha's Vineyard, making it easy to get around all over the island. The cleanliness of the rooms was exceptional, with spacious accommodations that were super clean. The staff at the hotel were friendly, knowledgeable, warm, and helpful. Additionally, the hotel facilities included amenities like a Keurig coffee machine, microwave, and refrigerator in the rooms.

For us, it was ideal.

The hotel room was clean and well-maintained. The bed was comfortable and I had a good night's sleep. I also appreciated the convenient location close to many restaurants. I would recommend this hotel for a pleasant stay.

As foreign tourists, we loved the clean and updated hotel with beautiful decor. The attached restaurant, Town MV, was lively and offered delicious food. The central location made it easy to explore all parts of Martha's Vineyard.

Felt truly spoiled, nothing was too much trouble.