The room at Hickory Grove Motor Inn featured a lovely lake view, comfortable beds, and convenient amenities like a coffee machine, microwave, and refrigerator. Everything was well-designed, making for a comfortable stay.

Musty odor in the room.

Great location near the lake, offering a peaceful and quiet atmosphere. The staff is friendly, providing helpful recommendations for restaurants and attractions. The rooms are clean and cozy, with a nice view and privacy. a pleasant experience.

Clean and cozy room with a great view of the surrounding nature. Convenient location near Glimmerglass Opera. Friendly and helpful staff. Enjoyed the peaceful atmosphere away from the city.

Comfortable rooms, friendly staff. Beautiful lake views, convenient location near Baseball Hall of Fame. Clean and well-maintained with helpful staff. Nice outdoor seating area. Discount tickets available at front desk.

The hotel was clean and cute, and the staff was very helpful and nice. The location on the lake was beautiful, and I liked that it wasn't in the center of town, even during the off-season.

All was perfect.

Our room had a beautiful view of the lake, trees, and flowers. The staff was friendly and helpful throughout our stay. We liked the convenience of being able to park right in front of our room. The hotel was clean and quiet, and the off-season rates were a great deal.

All was perfect.

Spent the day at the Baseball Hall of Fame and then drove up the road to the Hickory Grove Motor Inn. We were warmly greeted upon arrival, provided brief instructions about the continental breakfast then shown how to get to the lake. Our room was comfortable, clean and featured a fridge and writing table with padded chairs. Although we stayed during the fall colors time it's easy to see why it would also be a great place during the warmer summer months. Staff was friendly, addressed issues immediately, room was cleaned each day even though we didn't request that on a daily basis, nice view of the lake, quiet location.

Would recommend this hotel.

During our Christmas stay, we really enjoyed the cleanliness and adequate facilities of the hotel. The rooms were spacious and had comfortable beds, along with a sofa for extra seating. The presence of a mini-fridge and microwave oven was also a convenience. Additionally, the hotel's location offered beautiful views of the lake, making our stay even more enjoyable.

There were a few aspects that we were not completely satisfied with. The shower stalls were cramped, which made showering a bit uncomfortable.

We loved the beautiful view of the lake and the convenience of parking right in front of our room. The hotel staff was friendly and welcoming. The location was great, with plenty of attractions nearby and a short walk to the lake.

Nothing it is perfect.

I had a great view of the lake from my room at Hickory Grove Motor Inn. The room was clean and comfortable, and I appreciated the effort put into maintaining cleanliness. Although the shower was small, it served its purpose. I would recommend this hotel for its great view and clean rooms.

I had an amazing stay at this motor inn. The value for money was great, and the room was clean and comfortable. The location was beautiful, with stunning views of the lake. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful.

The only thing that could've been better about the morning meal was having a larger breakfast area.

Great location near the lake and convenient to local attractions. The staff was friendly and helpful, offering great recommendations for places to eat and visit. The room was clean and comfortable, with a nice view of the lake. The motel had a cozy and homey atmosphere, making it a pleasant place to relax and unwind.

There were a few minor issues that detracted from the overall experience. The shower stall was small and could benefit from some updating.

No-frills, one-floor rustic inn with a charming lake view. Close to the baseball hall of fame. Reasonably priced and comfortable for a good night's sleep. Be sure to visit Schneider's Bakery for delicious baked goods and coffee in the area.

We had a lovely romantic escape at this hotel. The view from our room was breathtaking, with a beautiful lake just a short walk away. The room was clean and comfortable, creating a cozy atmosphere for our getaway. Additionally, the hotel's location was perfect for exploring nearby attractions such as the Cooperstown-Hall of Fame and Fennimore Art Museum.

There were a few downsides to our stay. The shower in our room was extremely small, making it difficult for taller or larger individuals to comfortably use.