This hotel had the best continental breakfast, with fresh bakeries and good coffee. The owners and staff were friendly, and the grounds, pool, and hot tub were well kept. I loved the peaceful area for reading and meditating in the morning. The location was convenient, close to everything on the peninsula.

Absolutely nothing.

The location of the hotel was convenient, being close to a grocery store and a good Italian restaurant. The motel also had a beautiful outdoor area with many tables adorned with fresh flowers, which created a pleasant ambiance. Additionally, the pool was lovely and there was even a fire pit available for guests to enjoy.

The beds and linens were not as comfortable as those you would find in higher-end hotels. It felt like a typical mom and pop motel, with minimal amenities and outdated decor.

Loved the convenient location and kind staff. Clean and quiet room. Refreshing pool and fire pit. Friendly breakfast setup.

Nothing it was perfect.

The rooms at this charming inn were clean and pleasantly updated, providing everything we needed for our romantic escape. The friendly and helpful staff made us feel welcome from the moment we arrived. We also loved the beautiful outdoor space with gas fire pits, which created a cozy atmosphere for enjoying the evenings together. The location was perfect, just a short drive away from downtown Sister Bay and other nearby attractions.

While the continental breakfast offered a decent variety of options, it could have been better in terms of quality and selection. We found that some of the breakfast items lacked freshness and could have been more appealing.

We stayed at this hotel for 4 days and 3 nights and were pleasantly surprised by several positive features. the rooms were spacious and well-furnished, with the unique addition of a fridge and freezer. Additionally, the hotel's backside offered a peaceful setting with a pool, hot tub, firepit, and outdoor seating. The landscaping around the grounds was well-tended and added to the overall charm of the place. The staff was friendly and attentive, and the room was tastefully decorated and clean. a great experience that we would recommend to friends and family.

Couldn't recommend this hotel more.

Best aspects of this place were the convenient location and friendly staff! We were close to the downtown area but far enough away for a quiet night's sleep. The pool and hot tub were clean and a great way to relax after a long day of work.

Worst aspects were the lack of sustainable practices, such as disposable plates and cutlery for breakfast and single-use toiletries in the bathroom. Additionally, the early checkout time of 11:00 am was a bit inconvenient for business travelers.

As youngsters, my boyfriend and I loved the convenient location, just a short walk from the heart of town. The renovated rooms with laminate flooring were modern and clean, and the comfortable bed ensured a good night's sleep. We appreciated the continental breakfast, which we could order in advance and have delivered to our room. The friendly staff made us feel welcome, and the well-maintained grounds and pool added to the pleasant atmosphere. a great choice for a quick getaway.

Felt well taken care of, no complaints.

This hidden gem in Door County exceeded my expectations. The rooms were spotless and the private green space in the back was a delightful surprise. Enjoying the firepit and pool while soaking up the morning sun was the perfect start to the day. The owners clearly take pride in keeping the property updated and clean. The amenities in the room were great, including a Keurig coffee maker and a compact fridge/freezer. The friendly staff made my stay even more enjoyable. I highly recommend this hotel to family and friends.

Can recommend this hotel.

The value for money was excellent, with a clean room and no carpet, which I appreciated. The location was convenient with shops and restaurants nearby, and the staff treated me with friendliness and responsiveness.

The breakfast could be improved with an earlier start time.

This hidden gem is a budget traveler's dream. Clean rooms, friendly staff, and a beautiful pool and hot tub.

Felt like in a fairy, nothing to complain about.

We stayed at this charming inn for 3 nights and it exceeded our expectations! The rooms were cozy and clean, and the staff was friendly and helpful. The breakfast, although minimal, was well-maintained and better than expected. The highlight was definitely the fancy fire pit, which we absolutely loved. The hot tub was also open earlier than scheduled, which was a pleasant surprise. The grounds were beautifully landscaped with flowers, and the location allowed us to easily explore several nearby parks and towns. a fantastic stay!

I do recommend this hotel.

The outdoor areas are beautiful with fresh flowers and plenty of seating. The pool and whirlpool are clean. The continental breakfast is above average and well stocked. The staff is friendly and helpful. The location is convenient for exploring nearby attractions.

Cleanliness - The rooms at this hotel are nicely decorated and very clean. Hotel facilities - The hotel has a clean heated pool with lots of towels, as well as a grill, picnic table, and chairs in a secluded backyard. Parking - The hotel has a spacious parking lot, which is very convenient. Location - This hotel is conveniently located close to downtown and the marina, making it easy to explore the area on foot or by car. Breakfast - The hotel offers a small but nice breakfast area, which is a great way to start the day. Staff - The owners of this hotel, Alma and Will, were always present and provided friendly service, offering helpful suggestions for local attractions and attending to all our needs.

Nothing I didn't like to be fair.

We were those taking off early - Loved room 127 with a sunny balcony, larger space, and laminate flooring. Ron at the desk was pleasant and accommodating. Super clean hotel!

Felt like part of the family, no complaints.

For the price, it's hard to beat Sister Bay Inn. The room was clean, newly remodeled, and had all the amenities we needed. Plus, the location was perfect - just a short walk to downtown and all the shops and restaurants. The family staff was incredibly friendly and made us feel right at home.

The breakfast offerings could use more fruit options.