The rooms were beautiful and the pools were amazing. The hotel was well-maintained and the decor was charming. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The breakfast was delicious and served in a lovely setting. The location was great, with a fantastic restaurant just a block away. The bar had an honor system, which was unique and convenient.

The reception staff was not very welcoming and seemed indifferent towards guests. There was a lack of communication from the owners, who were not present during our stay.

Cleanliness was top-notch, and the hotel facilities were superb. Parking was convenient, and transportation options were easily accessible. The location near the beach was perfect for enjoying the beautiful Long Island coastline. The breakfast spread was delicious, and the staff was friendly and attentive.

Nothing, everything was great.

Immaculate grounds, upscale B&B, awesome staff, great accommodations for families, excellent service, free earring return.

Absolutely nothing to say about dislikes.

Immaculate grounds, awesome staff, personalized treatment. Superb terrace for breakfast, beautiful decor, peaceful pools. Flawless job by friendly and skilled spa technicians. Owner attentive and caring. Worth every penny, plan a longer stay.

Romantic hotel, gorgeous grounds, helpful staff, alternative furnishings, can't wait to go back, peaceful and perfectly maintained grounds.

Absolutely nothing.

The most romantic hotel, gorgeous grounds, helpful staff, high-quality breakfast, comfortable living room.

No negatives from this place.

I had a wonderful time with my family at this upscale B&B. The grounds were immaculate and the staff was awesome. The accommodations and service were great, especially for our family. They even sent my daughter's lost earring back to us free of charge. The location was perfect for walking around the community. The room was quaint with a comfortable bed and spacious bathroom. The property was amazing with outdoor and indoor pools. The staff was delightful and extremely helpful. The decor was beautiful and unique. Can't wait to go back!

Totally recommend this hotel.

Gorgeous rooms with comfy beds and oversized bathtubs. Cozy lounging and dining areas with beautiful decor. Conveniently located, close to shopping and restaurants. Great breakfasts and other amenities.

None mentioned in the reviews.

Friendly staff. Delicious breakfast with fresh juice and berries. Cozy living room with a massive fireplace. Excellent location, walkable to shops and restaurants.

I recently stayed at a hidden gem in the Hamptons and had the most incredible experience. The level of service at this exclusive B&B was unparalleled. They went above and beyond to accommodate my needs, providing a playpen and high chair for my young daughter. The breakfast was the best in the area and the spa was top-notch. The rooms were not only cozy, but also beautifully designed by a professional interior designer. The atmosphere was welcoming and I immediately felt at home among the cool and friendly guests. I even had the pleasure of meeting the amazing owner at one of the events. If you're visiting the Hamptons, I highly recommend staying at this amazing establishment. I'll definitely be recommending this hotel to everyone I know.

The Baker House was a beautiful oasis! The grounds were peaceful and perfectly maintained, pools heated, original charm intact, amazing staff, and top-quality spa. The owner genuinely cares about guests. Worth every penny and worth planning a longer stay.

Would be happy to recommend this hotel.

The Baker House exceeded my expectations in every way. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm hospitality and a stunning atmosphere. The rooms are beautifully decorated and the beds are incredibly comfortable, ensuring a restful night's sleep. The breakfasts were a highlight of my stay, with delicious food that surpassed any I've had elsewhere. The location is ideal, just a short walk away from shops and restaurants in East Hampton. I highly recommend this hotel for its luxurious accommodations, impeccable service, and convenient location.

This hotel is a hidden gem with beautiful grounds, a romantic atmosphere, and helpful staff. The outdoor terrace for breakfast is superb, and the original charm and architecture of the house adds to its appeal. The pools, both indoor and outdoor, are heated and perfect for enjoying on warm days. The spa services are excellent, with top-notch technicians. The location is ideal for exploring the community of East Hampton, with shops and restaurants within walking distance.

Felt extremely welcome, no complaints at all.

The property is stunning, especially in the spring. The Fifthian room was cute and comfy, with everything super clean. The breakfast was delicious, and the spa was special and beautiful. The staff was adorable, and we wish we could have stayed longer.

Felt very well taken care of, nothing to complain about.

We got great value for our money at the Baker House. The room was comfortable and the location was ideal. The staff treated us like family and went above and beyond to make our stay memorable.

The menu for breakfast could benefit from better communication among the wait staff. We had to wait for cream with our coffee on two occasions.