The staff was amazing and very attentive to all our needs. They made us feel welcome and were always available to help with any inquiries or requests we had. The location of the hotel was also a huge plus. It was conveniently situated close to all the attractions and restaurants in the city, making it easy for us to explore the area on foot. Additionally, the overall layout of the room and hotel was well-designed and aesthetically pleasing, creating a comfortable and enjoyable atmosphere.

There were a couple of downsides during our stay. the parking situation was quite problematic.

The hotel is conveniently located near the town center, making it easy to explore the area and visit Martha's Vineyard. The staff is friendly and accommodating, providing excellent service throughout our stay. The rooms have a charming old-world charm with slanted ceilings, adding a unique touch to the overall ambiance. The breakfast included is homemade and full of delicious surprises, definitely a delightful start to the day.

All aspects of our stay were satisfactory.

The location of this boutique hotel is fantastic, right in the heart of the charming town. Everything you need is within a short walking distance, from fine dining to boutique shops. The rooms are modern and upscale, and the staff, especially Stephan, is friendly and helpful. The outdoor patio is a great place to relax, and the breakfast options are delicious. The hotel has a lovely coastal vibe and provides a wonderful getaway experience.

Some of the furnishings in the rooms may be a bit outdated or dirty.

I had a wonderful stay at this charming B&B and highly recommend it. The location was perfect, with easy access to restaurants, shops, and the harbor. The staff, particularly Alison and Mariel, were fantastic and provided us with great recommendations and even an anniversary upgrade. The newly decorated main house was beautiful and comfortable. The homemade breakfast in a crate was a delightful touch. Despite the lack of a table, the bed was so comfy that we didn't mind. I had a great experience at The Sydney and would definitely return.

Great location, delicious continental breakfast, outstanding restaurant and bar, convenient parking, friendly staff.

None.

The location of this hotel is absolutely ideal! You are in the very centre of town and so close to everything downtown in Edgartown. The staff is super friendly and accommodating, and the rooms are cozy with comfortable linens.

All was well, nothing to complain about.

Beautifully designed rooms with nautical touch, top-notch toiletries, great breakfast, perfect location in town center, attentive staff, water and Kombucha station.

Was all great.

I was pleasantly surprised by my stay at this hotel. The room was impeccably clean and the location was great. The breakfast was unique and delicious. The staff was welcoming and helpful. I highly recommend Sydney.

The hotel's location is exceptional - it is so close to everything downtown in Edgartown. We loved that it was in the center of the city, making it convenient to walk to restaurants and shops. Despite being so close to the town center, it was surprisingly quiet, allowing for a peaceful stay.

Was all great.

Great location, helpful staff, delicious breakfast delivered to your room upon request. Lovely decor and outdoor seating options. Pleasant amenities like coffee and cookies available throughout the day.

Exceptional staff and location. Innovative breakfast options, including mini bagels and sliced ham/cheese plate. Coffee service available for early risers. Immediate phone availability for any questions. Beautiful, bougie boutique feel with simple but enjoyable continental breakfast. Attentive and accommodating staff. Accessible water and Kombucha station. Afternoon treats and fire pit add to the overall experience. Would definitely stay again.

Great location, close to restaurants and shops. Nice coastal decor in the hotel. Outdoor patio for relaxing in the evening

Room was very small. Noisy at night due to a nearby restaurant.

I was pleased to make the trip to Martha's Vineyard and found this hotel to be a great choice. The location was perfect, as it was close to the town center yet quiet enough for a peaceful stay. The staff went above and beyond in providing recommendations on what to do on the island, which was extremely helpful. The rooms were charming with their slanted ceilings and the basic amenities provided were more than satisfactory. Additionally, having breakfast included was a fantastic perk.

Everything was okay.

Excellent central location for exploring restaurants and activities. Clean, comfortable rooms with nice bathroom amenities. Spacious and beautifully decorated with two common guest areas. Continental breakfast delivered to your room each morning. Friendly staff.

The central location was very convenient for getting around and exploring the town. the staff were friendly and gave great advice on local breakfast spots. having the option of leaving our car parked all day was a great bonus.

We found the bedding to be of poor quality and uncomfortable for sleeping. the lack of noise insulation in the rooms made it difficult to get a good night's rest with outside noises and music from nearby establishments.