Great ambience, superb staff, easy access to trains into NYC, historic Grain House tavern/restaurant with excellent food and service.

Felt really welcomed, no complaints at all.

During my recent stay at the Olde Mill Inn, I had a truly charming experience. The wedding we attended was held at the hotel and it was absolutely beautiful. The food served during the event was top-notch and delicious. Additionally, our room was spotlessly clean, which was a huge plus. The location of the hotel in this picturesque area added to the overall charm and ambiance. Despite a few minor inconveniences, I would highly recommend this hotel to others looking for a lovely stay.

The Olde Mill Inn is so quaint and clean! The balcony and garden were perfect for enjoying coffee in the morning. The room had a real mug and even pen and paper, which was very convenient. The restaurant was just a short walk away and served great food. The breakfast with perfectly cooked eggs and delicious coffee was a highlight.

The staff was outstanding and very accommodating. The grounds and courtyards were beautiful.

As young people, we absolutely loved the charming courtyard filled with beautiful flowers. The cozy bed and the peaceful garden balcony were perfect for relaxing with our coffee. The real mugs and the complementary pen and paper were convenient touches. The nearby restaurant served delicious food, especially the perfectly cooked eggs for breakfast. the decor, comfort, and helpful staff made our stay at this gem of a hotel truly enjoyable.

We felt like part of the family at this hotel, where nothing was too much trouble.

The courtyard flowers were lovely, and the bed was comfortable. The manager took $50 off the price when I mentioned noise in the courtyard at night.

Felt well taken care of, staff went above and beyond.

I love the cozy atmosphere and horse country theme of this inn, and the staff were very pleasant and accommodating. The room was clean and comfortable, and I appreciated the extra touch of having a "Pure" room for those with allergies. The Grain House restaurant was enjoyable and historic. I had a wonderful getaway and would definitely stay here again.

Very comfy rooms. Porch with garden view. Convenient location near interstate. Luxurious accommodations. Fun historic atmosphere. Landmark restaurant. Close to big box stores. Family-friendly activities nearby.

Can't think of anything.

I recently stayed at the Olde Mill Inn for a few days and it was a great experience. The rooms were comfortable and cozy, perfect for a good night's rest after a long journey. The location was convenient, right off the interstate, making it an ideal choice for both travelers and those looking for a luxurious stay. The hotel has a rich history and the porch overlooking the interior garden was a lovely spot to relax. The Grain House Restaurant, a cool landmark, was a great place to enjoy meals. Additionally, there is a nearby garden nursery and farm where you can enjoy picking your own apples, perfect for a fun family activity.

Can recommend this hotel.

Quaint & clean. Spacious room. Cozy bed. Balcony & garden. Real mug & pen. Nearby restaurant. Perfect eggs & coffee.

Everything is what i need and want.

Stayed at this elegant venue for a wedding reception and was blown away by the rustic charm of the estate. The French doors leading to the courtyard and English gardens were enchanting. The food was outstanding with a variety of options, including a vegetarian meal. The 102 rooms were tranquil and allowed all guests to fully enjoy the celebration. I highly recommend this venue for a memorable and exquisite experience.

The hotel is conveniently located near the airport and offers spacious and cozy rooms. The hot breakfast was basic but satisfying. The staff were friendly and the room was clean and comfortable. The hotel has a nice garden area with a fireplace. a pleasant stay.

I had a fantastic stay at this hotel. The cleanliness was impeccable, from the spotless rooms to the well-maintained garden. The hotel facilities were top-notch, with a beautiful balcony overlooking the garden and a convenient business center. The location was perfect, with easy access to trains into Penn Station NYC and the Basking Ridge Country Club. The staff was friendly and accommodating, making my stay even more enjoyable.

There was nothing I didn't like.

Comfortable and clean room with spacious balcony and garden. Convenient pen, paper, and real mug provided. Great restaurant nearby with tasty food options. Friendly and professional staff. Ideal location for those visiting the area.

I recently stayed at a charming hotel in a beautiful area for my brother's wedding. The wedding was absolutely lovely and the food served was excellent. The room we stayed in was impeccably clean, although the mattresses were a little bouncy. Despite that, our overall experience was great and I would recommend this hotel to others.

Great location off the GSP exit for easy access. Friendly and helpful staff. Enjoyed the warm and welcoming lobby. The king room on the lower level was comfortable and had a second door that opened to the courtyard. Appreciated the special "Pure" room for guests with allergies. The horse country theme throughout was charming. The Grain House restaurant next door offered enjoyable and historic dining.

Unexpected noise from business people using the seating areas, which took away from the quaintness of the hotel. Loud conversations and large parties made it difficult to have a peaceful dinner at the Grain House.