Friendly staff, delicious food, beautiful sunset views, excellent location for dinner and cocktails.

Gorgeous views of the bay and small beach from terrace and pool area. Saltwater pool is nice. Staff is friendly and accommodating, and the hotel supports local youth employment. Enjoyed relaxing in the sunrooms and on the deck. The hotel has a charming old Long Island feel. Homemade granola is a tasty treat.

Felt safe and secure, nothing to complain about.

We had a wonderful stay at this luxurious hotel! The location on the Bay was absolutely stunning, offering breathtaking sunset views while enjoying a delicious dinner or sipping cocktails. The staff, mostly from Ireland and the UK, were incredibly friendly, courteous, and helpful, making us feel right at home. The hotel itself exuded charm and history, with old-fashioned room keys and other delightful artifacts. The accommodations were spotlessly clean, and the bed was incredibly comfortable, ensuring a quiet and restful night's sleep. The full breakfast buffet was a treat, with a wide variety of options to choose from.

Our stay at this hotel was fantastic and we would highly recommend it to family and friends.

Love the ambience, fabulous location, great amenities, delicious food, friendly staff, amazing view.

Nothing, all great.

Great location, with a small beach and saltwater pool. Complimentary champagne and oysters on Saturdays. Friendly and helpful staff. Quiet getaway with comfortable beds. Fabulous dinner and cocktails available, no need to leave the property.

If you're looking for a relaxing vacation without high expectations for entertainment and dining, The Pridwin in Shelter Island is the perfect place. Despite small rooms and outdated furniture, it was one of my best vacations. The lack of people and peaceful atmosphere made it a great getaway. The pool was warm and clean, and the beach, while rocky, offered beautiful views. Renting a boat from Peconic Water Sports was amazing and worth every penny. The staff, although lacking in management, were pleasant. The homemade breakfast and Alvin's granola were delicious.

I recommend this hotel.

The view, room cleanliness, retro bathroom, low-key yet sophisticated vibe, friendly staff.

Everything great.

We stayed at The Pridwin for a few nights and loved every moment. The view from our room was breathtaking, overlooking the private beach, docks, and the bay. The room was clean and had a nice retro touch, with subway tiles and black & white hexagon floor tiles in the bathroom. The hotel had a perfect low-key and sophisticated vibe, with friendly staff who made us feel like family. The 4th of July BBQ on the front lawn was a highlight of our stay. Reserving a room at The Pridwin is now a tradition for our family's summer travels.

I recently had a wonderful stay at a charming hotel on a beautiful island. The room I stayed in had an updated bathroom with a lovely, timeless subway tile design. The best part was the hot shower with excellent water pressure - it was so relaxing. The hotel itself had beautiful and clean common areas, and the staff was excellent. The value for the end-of-summer special rate was amazing, especially considering the BBQ night and breakfast included in the package. The hotel hosted a BBQ party with a live band, and it was a great atmosphere with families, couples, and hotel guests all enjoying themselves. I had a fantastic experience and will definitely be returning every summer. I highly recommend this hotel.

The breakfast included in the rate was a nice perk and gave me a good start to the day. The location of the hotel was also great as it was situated in a quiet area, away from the hustle and bustle of the city. Plus, the view from the dining deck was absolutely stunning and added to the overall experience.

There were a few aspects of my stay that I didn't enjoy. the noise levels in the hotel were unbearable at times.

A bit of Paradise

We had a really nice stay at this hotel. The staff was amazing and very friendly. The location was perfect, just a few steps away from the water and many restaurants. We loved the complimentary champagne and oysters offered on Saturday, and the pool had a beautiful view.

The facilities and room rate didn't really match up. The room wasn't very clean, and the service in the bar and restaurant was lacking.

Located on a hill, our car journey to the hotel offered breathtaking views of the bay and surrounding area. The hotel also provides a beautiful boat for scenic tours of the bays, giving guests a unique experience on Shelter Island. The room we stayed in was cozy and the bathroom was clean and well-maintained. The staff provided friendly and attentive service, ensuring our needs were met throughout our stay. Additionally, the complimentary breakfast offered a variety of options, including fresh seafood.

The pool area became crowded at times, making it difficult to find available lounge chairs.

We had a fantastic stay at this hotel. The location on the beach on Shelter Island was perfect, providing a beautiful and peaceful getaway. The hotel facilities were excellent, with a sunny and warm pool, as well as kayaks, boats, and paddle boards available for use. The cleanliness of the hotel was top-notch, with everything well-maintained and in great condition. The staff at the hotel were welcoming and attentive, making sure that all our needs were met. The breakfast each morning on the porch was a highlight, with delicious food and stunning views to start our day.

Nothing to be said.

I loved the view from our room overlooking the private beach and docks. The location of the hotel was perfect for exploring the beautiful bays of Shelter Island. The cleanliness of the room was impressive, and the retro bathroom tiles added a nice touch. The friendly staff made us feel like family, and the food at the restaurant was excellent.