Find and Book Top Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Search among 12 available hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island Heights from 50+ providers

Check-in
Select date
Check-out
Select date
Rooms & Guests
22 Guests, 1 Room
Filter & Sort
View map
1-12 out of 12
Filter & Sort
View map
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
7.6
Very good5 reviews
From   US$ 357 /nightSelect
Places to stay near Shelter Island Heights
7.8
Very good26 reviews
MapView on map1.5 km from Shelter Island Heights1.5 km from City Centre1.8 km from Dering Harbor Marina
From   US$ 596 /nightSelect
7.4
Very good9 reviews
4.6 km from Shelter Island Heights4.6 km from City Centre
From   US$ 186 /nightSelect
8.4
Great51 reviews
2.0 km from Shelter Island Heights2.0 km from City Centre
From   US$ 287 /nightSelect
Hotel
8.4
Great59 reviews
10.4 km from Shelter Island Heights10.4 km from City Centre
From   US$ 219 /nightSelect
8.4
Great62 reviews
3.7 km from Shelter Island Heights3.7 km from City Centre
From   US$ 409 /nightSelect
Bed & Breakfast
8.0
Great26 reviews
2.3 km from Shelter Island Heights2.3 km from City Centre
From   US$ 299 /nightSelect
8.4
Great29 reviews
6.1 km from Shelter Island Heights6.1 km from City Centre
From   US$ 405 /nightSelect
8.4
Great40 reviews
2.1 km from Shelter Island Heights2.1 km from City Centre
From   US$ 170 /nightSelect
8.6
Great8 reviews
1.3 km from Shelter Island Heights1.3 km from City Centre1.6 km from Dering Harbor Marina
From   US$ 823 /nightSelect
8.6
Great43 reviews
2.3 km from Shelter Island Heights2.3 km from City Centre
From   US$ 334 /nightSelect
8.4
Great54 reviews
2.2 km from Shelter Island Heights2.2 km from City Centre
From   US$ 371 /nightSelect

Best Hotels and Places to Stay in Shelter Island Heights

Why Visit?

Shelter Island Heights, located in the United States, is a charming tourist destination that offers a combination of natural beauty, historical attractions, and a relaxing atmosphere. With its picturesque scenery, proximity to the ocean, and a variety of activities, Shelter Island Heights is an ideal place to unwind and enjoy a peaceful vacation. Whether you are looking to explore the beaches, indulge in water sports, or simply relax in a tranquil setting, Shelter Island Heights has something to offer for everyone.

Where to Stay?

Shelter Island House: Situated in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island House is a popular choice for tourists. This boutique hotel offers elegant and comfortable rooms, each uniquely decorated with a blend of modern amenities and a touch of vintage charm. The hotel features a beautiful garden area, a spa, and an on-site restaurant, providing guests with a delightful and convenient stay.

The Chequit: Another excellent option for accommodation is The Chequit, a historic hotel that dates back to the 1800s. With its cozy and stylish rooms, this boutique hotel offers a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere. Guests can enjoy the hotels quaint front porch, socialize in the cozy lounge area, or explore the nearby shops and restaurants. The Chequits location makes it a perfect base for exploring Shelter Island Heights.

The Pridwin Hotel: Nestled on the waterfront, The Pridwin Hotel provides stunning views of the surrounding nature and offers a serene retreat for visitors. This family-owned hotel offers comfortable rooms and several amenities, including an outdoor pool, tennis courts, and complimentary use of bicycles. Guests can relax on the hotels private beach or enjoy a delicious meal at the on-site restaurant, which features fresh seafood and local produce.

What is the Price per Hotel Room per Night?

3-star hotels: The average price per night in Shelter Island Heights ranges from $200 to $300.

4-star hotels: The average price per night in Shelter Island Heights ranges from $300 to $400.

5-star hotels: The average price per night in Shelter Island Heights ranges from $400 to $600.

Best Value for Money:

Rams Head Inn: Offering a great value for money, Rams Head Inn provides a charming and comfortable stay in Shelter Island Heights. This hotel features spacious rooms with modern amenities, a picturesque garden, and an on-site restaurant serving delectable dishes made from locally sourced ingredients. With its reasonable prices and serene ambiance, Rams Head Inn is an excellent choice for budget-conscious travelers.

Dering Harbor Inn: Known for its affordability and convenient location, Dering Harbor Inn offers cozy accommodations with beautiful views of the harbor. The hotel provides comfortable rooms equipped with all the necessary amenities. Guests can enjoy the outdoor pool, relax in the peaceful courtyard, or take a short walk to explore the nearby attractions. Dering Harbor Inn is an ideal option for budget travelers seeking value for money.

Sunset Beach: This boutique hotel combines luxury and value, offering guests a unique and memorable experience. Located directly on the beach, Sunset Beach boasts stylish rooms with stunning ocean views. The hotel features a trendy bar and restaurant, where guests can savor delicious cuisine and enjoy refreshing cocktails. With its welcoming ambiance and affordable rates, Sunset Beach is an excellent choice for those seeking both comfort and value.

Best Kids-Friendly Hotels:

The Rams Head Inn: With its spacious grounds and family-friendly atmosphere, The Rams Head Inn is an ideal choice for families traveling with children. The hotel offers activities such as outdoor sports, nature walks, and even the opportunity to meet friendly farm animals in the vicinity. The comfortable rooms and on-site restaurant make it a convenient option for families with kids.

The Pridwin Hotel: The Pridwin Hotel caters to families with its array of amenities and child-friendly features. Kids can enjoy the outdoor pool, while parents relax on the private beach with stunning views. The hotel also offers complimentary use of bicycles, allowing families to explore the scenic surroundings together. With its welcoming atmosphere and activities for all ages, The Pridwin Hotel ensures a memorable experience for families.

Best Hotels for Romantic Getaway:

The Chequit: The historic charm and intimate ambiance of The Chequit make it a top choice for a romantic getaway. Couples can stroll hand-in-hand through the hotels beautiful gardens or relax on the cozy front porch. The hotel also offers romantic dining options at its on-site restaurant, providing the perfect setting for a romantic evening.

The Shelter Island House: Boasting elegant and tastefully designed rooms, The Shelter Island House offers a romantic and intimate atmosphere. Couples can unwind and rejuvenate in the hotels spa or enjoy a candlelit dinner at the on-site restaurant. The hotels proximity to picturesque beaches adds to its appeal for a romantic escape.

Best for Location:

The Rams Head Inn: Situated in a tranquil location with easy access to nearby attractions, The Rams Head Inn offers a convenient base for exploring Shelter Island Heights. Guests can enjoy the peaceful surroundings, take a walk along the nearby beach, or visit the nearby wineries. The hotels location allows for a peaceful retreat while still being close to the town center.

The Pridwin Hotel: Nestled on the waterfront, The Pridwin Hotel provides breathtaking views of the ocean and surrounding nature. Its location offers direct access to the beach, where guests can relax and enjoy the coastal scenery. Additionally, the hotel is just a short distance away from local attractions, making it an ideal choice for those seeking a convenient and scenic location.

The Chequit: Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, The Chequit provides easy access to the charming shops, restaurants, and historical sites in the area. Guests can explore the town at their leisure, visit nearby vineyards, or enjoy a boat ride around the island. The hotels central location allows for a convenient and enjoyable stay.

Best for a Short City Break:

Sunset Beach: Perfect for a quick escape, Sunset Beach provides a luxurious and modern setting for a short city break. Guests can relax on the beach, dine at the stylish restaurant, or enjoy the hotels vibrant nightlife. The hotels contemporary design and lively atmosphere make it a great choice for a short getaway.

Shelter Island House: With its blend of modern amenities and historic charm, Shelter Island House offers a unique and comfortable stay for a short city break. Guests can explore the nearby shops and restaurants, or simply relax in the cozy lounge area. The hotels central location and inviting atmosphere make it an ideal option for a quick escape.

Show moreLess