West Neck Guesthouse, Shelter Island Heights ** Special offers 2024 **, Top hotel in Shelter Island Heights ┆ Tophotels.com

View all

West Neck Guesthouse - Shelter Island Heights

Recommended for:

Relaxation seekersUnwind in the backyard of West Neck Guesthouse after a day of exploring Shelter Island, surrounded by a serene garden and peaceful atmosphere.

Morning coffee with a viewEnjoy your cup of coffee or evening aperitif on the private porch of the king deluxe room, which offers a lofty king bed, in-room mini-fridge, and a private full bath.

Ideal for familiesRoom 1 is perfect for couples traveling with children, offering a private king room, pull-out couch, and a well-appointed kitchen for convenience.

Delicious cocktails and snacksMake a stop at the hotel restaurant, 18 Bay, for refreshing cocktails and tasty snacks from the Enoteca on your way back from the beach.

Cozy living room with a kitchenStep into the living room, which includes a cozy nook with a full kitchen, plenty of sunlight, and a welcoming atmosphere.

Mini apartment experienceThe quaint suite at the West Neck Guesthouse provides extra space and a private kitchen, making it perfect for travelers who desire their own space.

Paddleboard yoga
Chic coastal decor
Private entrance retreat
Close to nature
Poolside relaxation
Unparalleled beauty
Quaint and romantic escape

Good to know

Timing

Check-in: 15:30-18:30FREE

Check-out: 11 amFREE

Children & extra beds

There are no cots provided in a room.

Pets

Pets are not allowed.

Rooms and availability

Deluxe King Room

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Room size:

23 m² Room size

Max:

2 persons

Coffee machine

Heating

Bathtub

Balcony

room details +

Check Prices

King Room

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Room size:

19 m² Room size

Max:

2 persons

Heating

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details +

Check Prices

King Suite

Bed options:

1 King-size bed

Room size:

46 m² Room size

Max:

2 persons

Heating

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details +

Check Prices

Facilities

General

Free Wi-Fi
Free parking
Safe deposit box

Dining

Picnic area/ Tables
Coffee/Tea in lobby

Spa & Leisure

Garden area

Room features

Sitting area
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Parquet floor

Location

• Situated in Shelter Island Heights, the guesthouse neighbors landmarks like Crescent Beach, Mashomack Nature Preserve, and Sylvester Manor Educational Farm. • The area offers cultural attractions like Shelter Island Historical Society, dining at establishments like Vine Street Cafe, and shopping opportunities at local boutiques. • For outdoor enthusiasts, Coecles Harbor Marina, Shelter Island Country Club, and nature trails at Mashomack Preserve are nearby.

31 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States, NY 11965

City landmarks
Nearby
Restaurants

Shelter Island Country Club

870 m

Sunset Beach

840 m

Event hall

Sylvester Manor Educational Farm

2.5 km

Beach

Crescent Beach

950 m

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

870 m

Church

Our Lady of the Isle Church

930 m

Sylvester Manor

1.4 km

Dering Harbor Marina

2.5 km

Market

The Gatehouse At Sylvester Manor

1.4 km

Amusement Park

Greenport Antique Carousel

3.1 km

Shelter Island Tennis Club

1.7 km

Church

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church

1.7 km

Manhansett Chapel Museum

2.0 km

Shelter Island Whale's Tail

2.0 km

Church

Saint Marys Episcopal Church

2.0 km

440 4th St at the LIRR Tracks

Railroad Museum of Long Island

2.9 km

Wiggins St Greenport Commercial Pier

Fireboat Firefighter Museum

2.9 km

519 4th St

Congregation Tifereth Israel

3.0 km

Museum

East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation

2.9 km

Front Street Mitchell Park

Camera Obscura

3.1 km

Museum

Havens House

2.4 km

Gallery

Nova Constellatio Gallery

3.3 km

3rd St

East End Seaport Maritime Museum

3.4 km

Island

Shelter Island

3.1 km

Harbour

Greenport

3.2 km

Fire Fighter Ship New York

2.8 km

Greenport Theatre

3.0 km

Long Island Train Museam

2.9 km

79 S. Ferry Rd.

Mashomack Preserve

3.6 km

Saint Agnes Roman Catholic Church

3.0 km

Shelter Island Country Club

420 m

Golf Course

Shelter Island Golf Course

390 m

Eagle Deli

1.1 km

25 W Neck Rd

The Flying Goat Restaurant

1.4 km

26 Sunnyside Drive Shelter Island Country Club

Shelter Island House

880 m

11 Stearns Point Road

Commander Cody's

470 m

Shelter Island New York

West Neck Guesthouse Reviews

9.8/10

United States, June 2024

Returning for Christmas; staff retrieved forgotten SIM cards. Place suits perfectly with Wi-Fi, free parking, flat-screen TV, air conditioning. No pets or smoking allowed – exactly what I need every visit.

8.4/10

United States, May 2024

We found this hotel to be exceptionally clean, well-renovated, and conveniently located close to the beach on Shelter Island. the room boasted a comfortable mattress, crisp ironed sheets, and a spacious bathroom. On-site parking was a plus, with excellent communication from the staff adding to the overall positive experience.

Cannot find any fault; our stay was flawless and enjoyable.

9.4/10

United States, March 2024

My recent stay at the guesthouse was delightful. the all-white decor, comfortable mattress, and spacious bathroom made me feel relaxed and refreshed. the property manager, Suzanne, was excellent with communication. the on-site parking was convenient, and the room had a safe deposit box in the closet. Despite some weekday morning noise due to the intersection, it was a clean and bright space. Overall, I highly recommend this hotel experience.

9.6/10

United States, March 2024

The guesthouse has clean rooms and comfortable beds. the staff is friendly and helpful. the location is convenient, close to restaurants and shops. the breakfast offered is delicious. Overall, a pleasant stay.

8.0/10

United States, March 2024

Comfy bed, clean, bright room, excellent communication, convenient parking.

Nothing could have been better.

9.2/10

United States, August 2023

the place is a beautifully renovated old home, super clean and bright with windows bringing in all that natural light. the comfy mattress and crisp sheets made for cozy nights, and having a large bathroom was such a bonus. Plus, the communication with Suzanne, the manager, was excellent! the convenient on-site parking really made things easier for exploring the area.

The only downside was a bit of noise during weekday mornings since the house is at an intersection.

10.0/10

United States, July 2023

I recently stayed for a weekend getaway at a charming spot, and I couldn’t have asked for a better experience. the beautifully renovated house was all white, exuding a clean and bright ambiance, aided by windows on three sides. My room featured ultra-comfy mattresses and crisp, ironed sheets that made sleeping a joy. the large, immaculate bathroom was a lovely perk, and I appreciated the roomy closet equipped with a safe. Plus, on-site parking was a convenience I didn’t expect, and Suzanne's communication was excellent throughout my stay.

I would recommend this hotel.