The hotel's location was excellent, with key attractions within walking distance. The lobby and bar were relaxing and well-appointed. Free bottled water in the room was a nice touch.

The rooms were small and in need of updating. The cleanliness left something to be desired, with the bathroom smelling of mildew and finding a hair tie from a previous guest in the bed.

The staff were professional and attentive. The room was comfortable and well-appointed. The hotel had a charming history that appealed to a writer and history buff.

The hotel is located in a prime spot, close to theaters and wonderful restaurants. It's in the heart of midtown, making it convenient to everything from Broadway shows to 5th Avenue shopping. The rooms are charming and clean, with just enough space for a weekend trip.

Some staff members were not professional or accommodating, which could have impacted the overall experience.

We were pleasantly surprised by the charming and historic ambiance of this hotel. The decor, with its ornate railings and beautiful tile floors, transported us back in time. Our suite was spacious, clean, and exceeded our expectations. The staff was friendly and accommodating, ensuring a pleasant stay. The location was perfect, just a short walk from Grand Central and close to everything we wanted to explore. We also had the pleasure of meeting Hamlet the cat, adding a unique touch to our experience. we highly recommend this hotel for its elegant charm and modern conveniences.

Excellent location, good room, nice bathroom, comfortable bed, historic charm.

Nothing everything was great.

During my stay at this venue, I was thoroughly impressed with the location as it was perfect and close to all the hotspots in Midtown. The service provided by the staff who truly made me feel most welcome and provided top notch accommodating service was exceptional. They even accommodated my request for non-alcoholic “cocktails” in coupe glasses. The room amenities, such as the soundproofed rooms and the mini-bar, were enhanced comfort and quality services. Additionally, the dining experience at the restaurant and the bar/lounge area were unforgettable.

I highly recommend this hotel, as it provided a top-notch and luxurious experience with friendly staff and great room amenities.

Immaculate cleanliness, fantastic location in Times Square Area, friendly staff.

Nothing for me.

Fantastic location, welcoming staff, great amenities, clean and spacious rooms, beautiful decor, excellent cocktails.

Nothing that I didn't like.

We loved the luxurious feel of this hotel. The decor was stylish and elegant, giving us a taste of Old New York. The staff were excellent and made us feel most welcome. The location was perfect, with theaters and shopping just a short walk away. We also enjoyed the amenities provided, such as the complimentary water and tea/coffee in the bar. The room was surprisingly spacious and the bed was incredibly comfortable. this place exceeded our expectations and we would definitely stay here again.

We highly recommend this hotel for everyone.

Quirky historic property with comfortable bed, central location, Blue Bar with friendly barmen, and beautifully serviced rooms. Helpful and friendly staff, including special lady, Matilda. Fantastic midtown stay with outstanding restaurant staff and surprise Saturday Jazz. One of the most special spaces in the City, especially for literary history buffs. Retained Algonquin ambiance in desirable lobby for enjoying a cocktail.

Great location and $25 credit for breakfast. However, the room and bathroom are small, and the bed was too soft.

Terrible service and bad experience. At check-in, had to wait 20 minutes and the hotel refused to honor the booked rate.

We had a fantastic stay at this hotel. The staff was extremely friendly and went out of their way to make us feel comfortable. The public rooms and our bedroom had a comfortable charm to them, giving us a feeling of stepping back in time. The hotel also had a resident cat, which added to its unique character. We also loved the fact that we received $30 per day to spend on food and drink purchased within the hotel. Additionally, we were provided with free tickets for the "Hop on hop off" tourist bus and a Grand Central Terminal tour. The location of the hotel was excellent, allowing us to easily explore all that this city has to offer. For meals, we discovered a great diner right next door that served delicious breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

All was perfect.

The suite was pristine, with a heavenly bed. The staff were helpful, friendly, and accommodating. Service was impeccable. Can't wait to return!

Loved the staff - especially Patricia - who were attentive and made us feel at home. The well-appointed room was comfortable and the bathrooms were newly renovated and clean. The hotel's rich history and enchanting atmosphere were a treat, especially for a writer and history buff like me. The location was excellent and the energetic lobby/bar added to the overall experience.

Felt immediately at home, no complaints.

Charming and historic hotel, conveniently located near popular attractions and within walking distance to key locations. Loved the character and old-style rooms. The dark bar and lounge added to the unique experience. Breakfast was good with a wide variety of options, and the omelettes were surprisingly light.

Front desk staff was preoccupied and rude, making us feel belittled. Slow service in the restaurant, both during busy and quiet times, resulting in a long wait for meals.