We had an amazing stay! The rooms were clean, comfortable, and beautiful. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable. The breakfast was delicious and served in a classy dining area.

My recent stay at the Benn Conger Inn was a wonderful retreat in the upper Cayuga Lake region. The inn provided the perfect base camp for exploring nearby Aurora and enjoying dining in Ithaca. The hosts were incredibly friendly and welcoming, and the breakfast they served was absolutely delicious. The inn has a rich history, reflected in its architecture, embellishments, and artwork. The attention to detail and quality throughout the property, from linens to food to staff, was truly impressive. I especially appreciated the cleanliness and the thoughtful touches, like the bottle of local champagne and welcoming card for our anniversary. The owners and staff are passionate about preserving the inn's historic charm while providing a memorable experience for guests. I highly recommend a stay at the Benn Conger Inn.

Would be happy to recommend this hotel.

Located in a serene and picturesque area, this charming inn offers a warm and cozy ambiance. The rooms are beautifully decorated and well-maintained, providing a comfortable stay for guests. The friendly and accommodating staff go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience. The homemade breakfast options are delicious, satisfying even the most discerning palates. Guests can also enjoy the stunning views from the private balconies and relax by the fire pit in the evenings.

The doors to the rooms can be quite loud when opening and closing, causing some disturbance.

Beautiful and historical decor with a warm, homey feel. Clean and comfortable rooms with a private balcony. Friendly hosts. Amazing breakfast buffet with homemade options.

We had a fantastic stay at Benn Conger Inn for a few nights while enjoying the beautiful fall foliage. The room and facilities were impeccably clean, and the hostess went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. The breakfast was excellent, and the innkeeper was extraordinarily accommodating. The cozy room, friendly staff, and impressive main house made our stay truly enjoyable. We highly recommend this hotel.

Beautiful historic inn, impeccable cleanliness, friendly and accommodating staff, delicious breakfasts, great location for exploring the area.

Nothing could have been better.

my second time staying here, and it was even better than before. drew, the owner, made us feel like family with his warm welcome and attention to detail. the cozy 2-bedroom suite was beautifully decorated and spotless. the evening fire pit gathering was unexpected but so enjoyable. breakfast was delicious and homemade. can't wait to come back!

We got great value for our money with a cozy room and delicious breakfast. The location was quiet and easy to get in and out of, and the staff treated us so well.

The staff at Benn Conger Inn were proactive in reaching out to ensure we had all the necessary directions. the house itself was better than expected for a typical B&B, with a cozy and beautifully decorated 2-bedroom suite. the personal communication from the owner and Inn Keeper made us feel reassured and well taken care of. the evening fire pit was a nice touch, creating a friendly atmosphere to gather. the home-cooked breakfast each morning was delicious.

All was perfect 😊

The serene location was a highlight, with fire ring and cozy rooms available. Breakfast options were diverse, including made-to-order dishes. Friendly staff ensured a comfortable stay. Personal touches like Easter basket and fire pit brought a sense of community. Ideal for visiting SUNY Cortland, only a short drive away.

the beautiful and cozy room had a fireplace and a huge bathtub. the Inn provided a lovely Easter brunch basket for us to enjoy, allowing us to have a relaxing morning picnic on our deck. the breakfast the next morning was delicious. the historical home of Benn Conger was beautifully furnished with period pieces and modern amenities. the hosts were hospitable and the homemade breakfast options were plentiful. It was a truly special experience and a perfect location to explore the Finger Lakes region.

Absolutely nothing 🙌

This stay was absolutely mind-blowing! The location was super convenient, with easy access to restaurants, wineries, and hiking trails. The hosts were incredibly friendly and welcoming, and the breakfast was delicious. The property had two buildings, and our room with a balcony was so quiet and peaceful. We loved that we could enjoy the common areas and outdoor gathering spaces. Drew, the host, was always available and made sure we had everything we needed. The cozy room and impressive main house added to the charm. Groton is a quiet town, but with a little planning, it was no problem finding places to eat. We're already planning our next trip back – this place is a jaw-dropping gem!

As longer-term business travelers, we thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this historic inn. The owner, Drew, personally welcomed us and provided a brief history of the property. The 2-bedroom suite we stayed in was beautifully decorated, clean, and cozy. The innkeeper, Shelly, was incredibly hospitable and ensured our every need was met. We appreciated the immediate response to our requests for additional amenities. The evening gatherings around the fire pit allowed us to meet and mingle with other guests, creating a friendly and enjoyable atmosphere. The home-cooked breakfast each morning was delicious and offered a variety of options. We also loved the convenient location, as it was only a short 15-minute drive from SUNY Cortland.

Felt very comfortable, no complaints.

the inn exceeded our expectations in every way. from the beautiful and historic furnishings to the impeccable cleanliness, every detail was thoughtfully taken care of. the breakfasts were delicious and the staff, especially Shelly, were incredibly hospitable and welcoming. we felt like royalty during our stay.

jacuzzi tub in the room lacked privacy

The main house is beautifully decorated with historical décor and art, creating a warm and homey atmosphere. The attached bathroom had a Jacuzzi tub/shower combination. The hosts were friendly and helpful, and the breakfast buffet offered a variety of delicious homemade options, including eggs benedict and cinnamon roll French toast.

The doors to the rooms were hard to open, close, and lock, resulting in loud slamming noises when guests entered or exited.