Great location close to ferry, shops, and dining. Spacious and newly renovated rooms with comfortable beds. Friendly cleaning staff provided excellent service. Pool area is a nice spot for relaxation. Complimentary breakfast treats were delicious.

I was blown away by the helpfulness of the staff at Faraway Martha's Vineyard. When I mentioned to the manager that I had trouble walking, they immediately arranged for a wheelchair to be available for me during my stay. It made exploring the island so much easier and more enjoyable. The hotel's dedication to accessibility really impressed me.

This hotel is perfect in walking distance to all the shops and restaurants as well as the yacht club. The staff at the hotel were incredibly attentive and provided excellent service. The rooms, located right off the lobby, had all the basic amenities needed for a comfortable stay. Additionally, the breakfast options at the nearby Black Dog Tavern were a great addition.

The only downside was that the rooms had very little air circulation even with the fan provided.

Staff excellent, helpful, great location, comfortable beds, updated rooms, complimentary milk and cookies.

No negatives from this place.

During my recent stay at Faraway Martha's Vineyard, I was pleasantly surprised by the beautiful location and comfortable accommodations. The rooms were clean and well-maintained, providing a relaxing atmosphere. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that all of my needs were met. I especially appreciated the complimentary cookies and milk in the evening, adding a delightful touch to my stay. The hotel also had ample parking, making it convenient for guests. I had a wonderful experience at Faraway Martha's Vineyard and would definitely recommend it to others.

I loved staying in Martha's Vineyard during the off season, as it meant no crowds and no traffic. Exploring the island without any hassle was such a treat. The hotel's location was perfect, close to many restaurants and shopping options. It was also conveniently located near the main attractions, including the family wedding we were there for. The cleanliness of the hotel was top-notch, and the facilities were cozy and warm. I particularly enjoyed being able to open the windows for cool air without any noise from the town. Moreover, the staff was friendly and knowledgeable, making our stay even more enjoyable.

Everything is what I need and want.

I recently had a very good stay at a hotel in the center of the most beautiful historic whaling village. The location was great, right in the heart of Edgartown, making it convenient to explore all the local attractions. The hotel itself was newly renovated and very clean, with a pleasing decor that captured the beachside vibe of the area. I particularly loved the rooms with a private balcony overlooking the water. It was a lovely spot to relax and enjoy the view. Additionally, the breakfast provided by the hotel was delicious and the staff were friendly and attentive. this hotel offered great value for money.

All was fine during my stay.

The hotel's location was excellent, centrally located and convenient. The pool was a hit for my daughter, she loved spending all day there. The warm chocolate chip cookies served every night were a delightful bonus. The staff was incredibly attentive and friendly, from reception to pool staff.

Couldn't stay longer.

This hotel is a gem! It has everything you need for a comfortable stay. The staff was friendly and helpful, making sure we had everything we needed. The location was perfect for exploring the historic whaling village, with plenty of shops and restaurants within walking distance. The rooms were recently updated with modern finishes, and the bed was super comfy. Breakfast was a treat with a great selection of muffins and hot drinks.

All was satisfactory, no complaints.

Located in the heart of the island, it’s easy to explore stunning beaches and try local restaurants. The room is nicely decorated and the bathroom is modern. Though there is no breakfast offered, fresh muffins and coffee are available every morning. In the evening, tasting cookies and hot chocolate are served free of charge in the lovely, cozy lobby. The pool area is clean and relaxing, perfect for a good day's end.

One small drawback was a lack of cleanliness in some areas of the hotel, but it didn’t bother us much.

Convenient central location, friendly and helpful staff, spacious and clean rooms, complimentary coffee and breakfast muffins, and snacks available in the lobby. Recommended for a getaway to Martha's Vineyard.

My recent stay at Faraway Martha's Vineyard was absolutely wonderful. I visited during the off-season and had the opportunity to explore the island without any crowds or traffic. The hotel's central location allowed me to walk to everything and it was also bike-friendly, making it easy to get around. The Kelley House, where I stayed, was cozy and warm. I loved being able to open the windows for cool air without any noise from the town. The front desk staff were incredibly helpful, answering my numerous questions and fulfilling my requests. I particularly enjoyed the delicious pistachio muffin and the tip from the front desk to visit the Carnegie Museum on Saturday.

Totally recommend this hotel.

The hotel had cookies and coffee available for guests, which was a nice touch. , the location was perfect being just a short walk away from both the beach and downtown. the beds were comfortable and the view from the room was beautiful.

The walls and floors were thin, so we could hear everything going on in the rooms adjacent to us. there was a lot of noise outside and we were woken up early in the morning by construction and delivery trucks.

We had a wonderful stay at a hotel in a great location. The room was clean and comfortable, and we enjoyed the pool area. The staff provided excellent recommendations for things to do in the area. we would definitely recommend this hotel for a great getaway.

The staff was friendly and helpful during our Christmas stay. The hotel had a cozy and warm atmosphere, and the location was perfect as it was situated in the heart of town. We were able to walk to all the shops and restaurants easily.

The hotel had limited beach chairs available. This was a bit disappointing as we expected more chairs for a hotel of this size.