I had a fantastic stay at this hotel - the location was perfect for me, being close to CMU, and the hotel facilities were top-notch. The cleanliness of the rooms was impeccable, and the staff was friendly and helpful. Breakfast offered a variety of fresh fruit options, which was a nice touch. Additionally, the hotel's beautiful lobby and public spaces, fully restored with plenty of character, made for a pleasant and relaxing atmosphere.

Nothing for me.

I had a fantastic stay at this hotel. The cleanliness of the rooms and hotel facilities were top-notch. The beautiful artwork throughout the mansion added to the historic ambience. The location in a lovely neighborhood of large older homes made for an enjoyable area for a morning walk. The staff was attentive and went above and beyond to make my stay comfortable.

Nothing, it is perfect.

Historic property with charming common areas, including Roaring 20's themed event. Spacious and clean room on the 3rd floor with large bathroom. Friendly staff and free parking. Ideal for a romantic getaway or overnight trip.

I stayed in a room with a fireplace, very comfortable bed, 12-foot ceilings, and antique furnishings. The hotel is located in a lovely neighborhood, with beautiful mansions nearby. The staff was friendly and accommodating.

There wasn't a wide choice of food available in the hotel pub and the bathroom floor tiles seemed old.

I had a wonderful experience staying at this luxurious hotel. The location in a great neighborhood was perfect for exploring nearby shops, bars, and restaurants. The service provided by the staff was excellent, from the warm welcome by the butler to the helpfulness of the reception staff. The room was clean and beautifully decorated, with comfortable bedding and a spacious bathroom. The hotel's unique artwork and original woodwork added to the overall charm of the place. The complimentary breakfast was delicious, and I enjoyed the cozy ambiance of the dining area.

I highly recommend this hotel to families looking for a luxurious and comfortable stay.

I recently stayed at this charming hotel and had a wonderful time. The room was cozy and clean, perfect for a relaxing stay. The hotel itself is filled with beautiful art and a historical ambiance that adds to its unique charm. The staff were friendly and always ready to assist with any questions or needs. Additionally, the location was ideal, with a vibrant strip of bars and restaurants within walking distance.

Can't recommend highly enough this hotel.

Great service from Ron, willing to assist with anything, even phone problems. Good quality and value breakfast. Beautiful interiors and comfortable rooms. Charming old house, clean and cozy. Fantastic bar and delicious drinks. Excellent location, quiet despite busy street. Impressive, though not cozy, large building with free parking.

The ambiance at Mansions On Fifth was truly enchanting. I felt like I had stepped back in time with the old-world charm and beautiful stained glass windows. The library and bar area were elegantly decorated with lovely tablecloths and flowers on the tables. The light furniture and dark wood created a cozy atmosphere that surrounded me. The staff was always available and attentive, making me feel well taken care of during my stay.

We're staying in a beautiful old house near a university with lots of lovely older homes. It's a great neighborhood and it was a perfect area for an enjoyable morning walk. We loved the spacious room and elegant atmosphere of the public spaces. The historic architecture was really impressive and everything was kept in great condition. Breakfast wasn't perfect, but still really nice with meat and cheese plates, fruit bowls, pastry plates and hard-boiled eggs. Service was fantastic with helpful staff.

Unfortunately we did experience some trouble with ceiling leaks during a rainstorm, it was handled but we wished the staff had been more prepared.

We loved staying at this place! The location was perfect for us - close to universities and a great neighborhood for walking. The staff provided excellent service, housekeeping was impeccable, and we had everything we needed in our room, like ironing facilities and free toiletries. The terrace was a great place to relax and enjoy the garden furniture. We especially appreciated the welcome drink and happy hour, as well as the fitness center and free Wi-Fi. We would definitely recommend this place to family and friends.

We had a fantastic experience here. There's really nothing negative to say - we were very impressed with the hospitality and amenities.

The bed was comfortable and the room had lots of windows, giving it a bright and airy feel. the hotel was located in a beautiful neighborhood, surrounded by other historic homes. Plus, the staff was extremely helpful and accommodating, making us feel welcome during our stay.

There were multiple weddings taking place at the hotel during our visit, which meant that the mansion portion of the hotel was off limits. This was disappointing as we had chosen this hotel specifically for its historic charm.

The hotel is conveniently located near Shadyside, a vibrant neighborhood with excellent restaurants. The area is perfect for a morning walk, with beautiful older homes and abundant trees. The hotel facilities were in the carriage house, which was cozy and charming. The staff was friendly and helpful, providing a list of nearby restaurants upon check-in.

N/A.

Lovely holiday decor, stained glass windows, and dark wood moldings. Clean bathroom with nice walk-in shower. Comfortable and spacious room. Live music, local beers, and upscale bar food at The Oak Room. Quiet during the week, busy with weddings on weekends.

Personable staff, cozy ambiance, close to Carnegie Mellon, dreamy bed, tasty breakfast.

No issues.

Close to Carnegie Mellon. Charming with well-kept historic charm. Bar and food available. Comfortable bed, large bathroom. Wonderful staff!