Centrally located, friendly staff, excellent breakfast, comfortable bed, nice tub.

Central location, friendly staff, excellent breakfast, comfortable bed, nice tub. Room gets hot in summer, but AC provided. Would stay again!

Centrally located, friendly staff, excellent breakfast, comfortable bed, nice tub, could use better AC.

Immaculate property, magazine-worthy look, comfortable room, well-appointed, makeup removers available in the bathroom.

Nothing bad to say.

The hotel is located in an appealing neighborhood, a few blocks away from the bustling Duval Street. The gardens are beautifully maintained and provide a peaceful oasis. On a sunny day, it's a great spot to relax and unwind. The breakfast options offered were fantastic, providing a delicious start to the day. The staff at this hotel were wonderful and gave excellent recommendations and made reservations for us, making our stay truly special.

Nothing negative to say.

The Mermaid & The Alligator is nestled in an appealing neighborhood several blocks removed from the clamor of the city center. It's located in a wonderful part of town, surrounded by magnificent gardens. Guests can relax and unwind with a glass of wine or fresh lemonade that is put out for them everyday. The location is close enough to walk or ride bikes to everything, making it convenient for exploring the area.

The absence of TVs in the rooms may be a drawback for those who enjoy watching their favorite shows during their stay.

As a business traveler, I loved the fresh and delicious breakfast options, with local coffee and handmade muffins. The cozy room had everything I needed and the location was perfect. The host, Maura, provided amazing recommendations for things to do.

Felt truly spoilt, no complaint.

The hotel offers incredible value for money, with affordable prices that are well worth every dollar. The attention to detail is outstanding, with beautifully furnished rooms that feel both homely and comfortable. The location is perfect for exploring new adventures, with a welcoming veranda and a large private balcony providing a relaxing space to unwind. One of the highlights is the breakfast on the deck, accompanied by live music from a local musician, creating a truly enjoyable start to the day.

All was absolutely fine, couldn't ask for more.

We had a wonderful time at this beautiful inn with its lush garden and charming decor. Our favorite part was the daily breakfast in the courtyard and the evening wine and cheese. The staff was helpful and made great recommendations for restaurants and activities. We'll definitely stay here again when we return to Key West. a delightful experience.

The rooms were clean and the outdoor patio area was beautifully maintained. the breakfasts were delicious and the small touches like coffee and afternoon wine and cheese were a nice touch.

The parking situation was inconvenient, with keys left in a bowl for anyone to move your car. the pool was more like a hot tub and not heated, which was disappointing.

I must say that I had a truly wonderful time at this hotel. The value for money was exceptional, especially considering the attention to detail and the level of service provided. The staff were friendly and welcoming, making me feel right at home from the moment I arrived. The basic amenities exceeded my expectations, and I particularly loved having a room with a large private balcony. It was the perfect spot to relax and take in the beautiful surroundings. Additionally, the breakfasts served on the deck were a true highlight. I loved starting my day with delicious food and live music from a local musician - it really added to the overall ambiance of the hotel.

All in all, my experience at this hotel was fantastic. There was nothing that I felt needed improvement during my stay.

The location was perfect, and we loved having our own private balcony in the Garden Room. The highlight of our stay was the delicious breakfast served each morning, and the staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. we would highly recommend this B&B.

Lovely breakfast options, convenient location, beautiful tropical surroundings, charming atmosphere, friendly staff.

For us it was ideal.

In my first B&B experience, the staff was friendly and the breakfast provided was excellent. The hotel's location is wonderful, surrounded by softly rustling tropical plants and in a wonderful part of town. Plus, it's so close to everything, making it easy to walk to all the attractions.

Nothing for me - it was a fantastic stay!

Beautiful tropical grounds and spacious pool. Custom-made breakfast with great variety. Charming older home and cottages. Cozy, private porches to relax on. Adult-only atmosphere adds to relaxed vibe.