Amara Cay Resort, Islamorada (FL) - Deals & Reviews

But that pool water might as well have come from a chilly Arctic sea. I could've used a warming spell instead of a swim!

Peaceful environment, beautiful scenery, complemented by the outdoor swimming pool where you can also enjoy the complimentary welcome drink and convenient beach access that made our short stay truly relaxing.

Nothing, all great

We loved lounging at the beautiful pool while our teenage kids enjoyed the water sports. The Tiki Bar was a great spot for cocktails and snacks. Plus, the staff was super friendly, making our family trip even more special.

My wife says that breakfast service could be quicker.

We enjoyed our time in a spacious room with a beautiful view and great vibes throughout the resort. The outdoor swimming pool and the beach access made relaxation super easy, with plenty of sun loungers available. Just a heads up, the restaurant service by the pool was a bit slow, but it didn't take away from our stay at all! 🌴

During our stay at Amara Cay Resort, it felt like we had discovered a hidden treasure in the Florida Keys! Picture this, lounging by the pool with a drink in hand, while the sunset painted the sky like a canvas of vibrant colors. The staff were like friendly pirates, helping us navigate our way through the resort and even sharing secret spots for the best views. The Tiki Bar was our favorite hangout, serving up delicious snacks as we enjoyed the ocean breeze—talk about paradise!

Mediocre shower.

Enjoyed the pool, the Tiki Bar's food was great, and we loved the complimentary shuttle service to nearby spots. The grounds are beautiful, making it easy to relax and connect over lawn games. Definitely recommend checking out the kayaking and biking activities—they're a must!

Our bathroom had a dim light that didn't work well, which made things a bit inconvenient. Fortunately, this didn’t ruin our overall fun, but I hope they address it. Housekeeping also missed some cleaning details which could use some improvement.

This place was just a good match for a concise stay in Islamorada with incredible value for money. The front desk was super helpful, getting us into our room quickly even though we arrived early and tired. Take full advantage of the kayaking and bike rentals—they're a lot of fun!

Hidden gem with a perfect view!

This place is such a chill spot! The beach access is right there, and the pool has insane views. We spent hours just lounging and enjoying the sun. Pro tip, don't miss the snacks at the poolside bar—they're delish! Only thing is, our room faced the parking lot, which wasn’t ideal, but it didn't ruin our vibe at all.

We stayed in a King Room with Partial Ocean View, and it was so comfy! The bed was great, and the view from the balcony was stunning. I loved waking up to the sun rising over the water. The room itself was spacious but just a heads up, there wasn't much natural light since it was a partial view. Still, the decor was modern and fit the vibe of the resort. Would definitely recommend for a chill stay!

Absolutely loved this place! ! So peaceful and relaxing, such a beautiful poolside atmosphere.

We stayed in a spacious oceanfront suite that was beautifully decorated and super clean. The view was amazing, and having a large balcony was such a treat! But honestly, the best part was the bed—it felt so comfortable, I didn’t want to get up! Just loved how relaxing everything was, from the room to the lovely outdoor areas. Definitely a great vibe overall!

I enjoyed my time here and appreciated the clean rooms with great views. The Tiki Bar was a highlight with friendly service. I made use of the complimentary shuttle, which helped us explore nearby spots for dinner. Cycling around the area was enjoyable, and I loved watching the sunrise from my room. I come from Italy, so I relished this slice of Americana. One thing to note is that cocktails were pricey, but we still had fun.

Awesome location but service could improve

The spot was really nice and had an amazing pool area! The breakfast at the poolside bar was tasty, but man, it took forever to get our orders. On top of that, our room wasn't cleaned during our stay, which was a bummer. Still, the views were fantastic and you can kayak for free, which was a plus!

Beautiful pool, spacious room with a comfortable bed, and the convenience of a restaurant on-site made our stay very enjoyable, especially with the complimentary shuttle service that made exploring the area so much easier.

Everything was superb.