I had an amazing stay at this luxurious hotel! The location was perfect, right across from a stunning view of the bay. The hotel is on a quiet street, which made for a tranquil and peaceful atmosphere. The service was exceptional, with the host being warm and welcoming. I loved the complimentary home baked treats in the afternoon and the delicious breakfast served on the porch every morning. The room was incredibly comfortable, with all the amenities of home. I felt like I was in a Parisian dream in the French Suite.

Families will definitely enjoy their stay here.

We had the best stay at a waterfront inn in Greenport. The hotel's location was perfect - within walking distance of amazing restaurants and close to both the town and the water. The room was cozy and clean, with a beautiful view of the water. The breakfast, prepared by the talented chef Clay, was absolutely delicious. We enjoyed a full hot meal made from scratch, and Clay's homemade treats in the afternoons were a delightful surprise. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel safe and comfortable. We can't wait to return for another relaxing weekend.

None.

Exceptional location, short walk. Personable and helpful Clay. Delicious and beautifully presented breakfasts. Pleasant surprise of jetted tub in Paris room. Complimentary homemade treats. Comfortable bed with ocean view. Convenient to restaurants and shops. Beautiful porch to watch sunset

Everything great.

Charming location, perfect for exploring town. Delicious breakfasts with amazing French toast. Friendly and helpful host. Exceptional service and homemade treats.

Could not be improved in any way.

Great view onto the bay. Quiet location. Excellent breakfast. Nice supply of refreshments

For us it was ideal.

We were delighted with our stay at The Stirling House. Clay, the owner, went above and beyond to ensure our comfort and satisfaction. The freshly brewed coffee and delicious breakfast quiche made for a perfect start to our day. The warm and welcoming atmosphere of the B&B, complete with snacks, DVDs, and games, made us feel right at home. Despite the rainy weather, we enjoyed the bay view from our room and appreciated the attention to detail in the amenities provided. We can't wait to return and highly recommend this wonderful inn. I highly recommend this hotel for a cozy and relaxing stay.

This hotel is located on a quiet street directly across from a stunning view of the bay. The service and housekeeping here are exceptional, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable stay. The staff provides a welcome drink upon arrival and is always ready to assist with tours or tickets. The rooms are well-appointed with heating and air conditioning, tea and coffee facilities, and a fully stocked mini-bar. There is a cozy sitting area and a terrace with a dining table, perfect for relaxing and taking in the surroundings. The rooms are soundproofed, ensuring a peaceful night's sleep. The hotel also offers garden furniture and free toiletries. Additionally, there is a well-equipped kitchen with cookware and kitchen utensils, as well as an electric kettle and an am/fm alarm clock. The flat-screen TV and parquet floor add a touch of luxury. Guests can also enjoy the convenience of a dining bar/lounge area and an outdoor dining area. The snack bar offers a variety of options, including special diet menus. The friendly and attentive staff is always available to assist guests, making the stay even more memorable. The leisure amenities include a sun terrace with sun loungers and a beautiful garden area with beach umbrellas. The hotel also offers leisure facilities such as a TV room and board games. The free wifi and off-site car park provide added convenience. this place provides a luxurious and comfortable stay with top-notch amenities and service.

I recommend this hotel to everyone.

The Stirling House Waterfront Inn was a fantastic place to stay. The owner, Clayton, was an amazing host and his cooking skills were out of this world. The breakfasts exceeded our expectations every day. The location was perfect and the room was fantastic. We felt so welcome and enjoyed our time at this little gem. I highly recommend this hotel for anyone visiting the area.

The breakfast was amazing and the staff were friendly and accommodating. The location was perfect, with easy access to the town centre and the water. The room was clean and spacious, and had a nice view.

The noise from the busy streets made it difficult to sleep at night. the decor in the common areas was outdated and could use some modernization.

I had a lovely stay at a small B&B walking distance from town. The view of Shelter Island from my room was beautiful and the owner, Clay, was hands off but able to provide guidance to other guests. The house was clean and tidy, and the homemade breakfast was delicious. Although I didn't have much time to enjoy the amenities, the B&B had a cozy atmosphere with a sitting area on the front porch and a sunroom. I would definitely recommend this cozy B&B!

Located on a historic street near shops and cafes, this B&B offers tranquil surroundings and a charming ambiance. The breakfast creations by the chef exceeded expectations, with a daily homemade treat in the afternoons. The exceptional service and warm welcome from the host added to the delightful experience.

The breakfasts were delicious and different each day, and the host was warm and welcoming. The location of the hotel was great, just a short walk from shops and cafes. The view from the porch and room was beautiful, overlooking the water.

I didn't have any complaints about the property or amenities as described.

Liked/Best aspects: Impeccable accommodations and great location! The rooms were very comfortable and the breakfast provided was excellent. The hotel's location was also a key factor for us, with a beautiful view of the water and just a few blocks away from the charming downtown area.

Disliked/Worst aspects: Unfortunately, the room amenities were not up to our expectations and the price seemed a bit high for what we received.

We had the most amazing time at this charming bed and breakfast. The location was perfect, right on the bay at the end of a dead end street. Our room was cozy and beautifully decorated, with a lovely view of the water. The bathroom was spotless and had all the amenities we needed. The host, Clay, was incredibly welcoming and made us feel right at home. The breakfast he prepared for us was absolutely delicious and we enjoyed it on the porch, taking in the stunning views. The overall experience was unforgettable.

I stayed in the Paris room, which had a jetted tub and it was a pleasant surprise. The location was exceptional, right on the bay at the end of a dead-end street. It was also very close to Greenport township and just a short walk to town. Plus, the hotel was right across from the bay. The breakfast served by the staff was not only delicious but also had a great presentation. The staff, especially Clayton, was very personable and helpful.

Nothing, all great.