Loved the setting of this hotel among the rolling hills of Amish Country! Also, appreciated the clean and spacious rooms with two sinks - perfect for privacy! The hotel's location was convenient to all the attractions we wanted to visit, and the staff were excellent - always going above and beyond to assist us. Additionally, the complimentary breakfast was a great start to the day and the fireplace in our room added to the cozy feel.

No negatives, everything was great!

The best aspects of this hotel were the cleanliness, hotel facilities, and location. The room was very clean and the hotel had a great pool area. The hotel is right in the center of beautiful Amish Country, which made it convenient for exploring. The staff were also excellent, providing great service throughout my stay.

Nothing all excellent.

The hotel is clean, has great facilities, convenient parking, and is located right in the center of beautiful Amish Country.

All was perfect.

I really enjoyed my stay at this venue. Being in the area for a short period of time, the location next door to the restaurant specializing in Amish cuisine was perfect for me. The service, from check-in to check-out, was exceptional. The indoor swimming pool and jacuzzi were great facilities to unwind in after a long day of exploring the nearby attractions. Additionally, the balcony attached to my room was a lovely touch and made my stay that much more enjoyable.

This hotel is highly recommended for families.

This extraordinary facility deserves 7 stars! We stayed at this hotel for 3 nights during our visit to the Amish county and the Giant Cuckoo Clock. The spacious rooms were beautifully finished and great value. The staff was super-helpful and kind, and the location in the middle of the countryside was quiet and relaxing. We enjoyed the delicious buffet at the nearby restaurant and loved the sunset view from our balcony. Plus, the availability of the bakery and gift shops added to the overall experience. A delightful place of comfort and calm, perfect for a romantic getaway or a family vacation.

Would recommend this hotel.

The hotel had beautiful facilities and a stunning view. The staff were friendly and made us feel like special guests. We enjoyed walking around the landscaped parking lot and exploring the old barn turned gift shop. The personal note from the staff, soft music in the lobby, and the building's decor created a retreat-like atmosphere.

The hallway had a bad smell, and our jacuzzi tub was not cleaned properly. The check-in process was confusing, especially because we booked through a third-party website.

This hotel exceeded our expectations in terms of value for money. The prices were very reasonable considering the size and cleanliness of the rooms. The attention to detail was impressive, with a lovely view of the countryside from our balcony and another sink across the hall from the bathroom. The staff were excellent, providing friendly and helpful service throughout our stay. We also appreciated the basic amenities, including the rooms with a pull out couch bed and the good facilities offered by the hotel.

All was great, no improvements needed.

Outstanding staff, delicious food, comfortable beds, pleasing room, beautiful scenery.

I had a great time staying at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek. The location was amazing, with a gorgeous balcony view that offered priceless sunsets. The hotel had a nice pool that was not overcrowded and the room was spacious. Despite a few drawbacks, overall I would definitely recommend this hotel.

Excellent breakfast, friendly staff, great pool and hot tub, comfortable rooms with beautiful view and upscale amenities.

Nothing that I didn't like.

This hotel truly exceeded our expectations in every aspect. the attention to detail was impeccable. The rooms were beautifully decorated with a cozy ambiance, and we especially loved the room with a balcony, which provided stunning views of the surrounding area. Secondly, the location was perfect. Situated right in the center of beautiful Amish Country, we were able to easily explore the nearby attractions in the village of Sugarcreek. Moreover, the hotel's proximity to a fantastic restaurant specializing in Amish cuisine was a delightful bonus. Lastly, the staff and service were outstanding. Everyone we encountered, from the friendly front desk staff to the attentive housekeepers, made us feel genuinely welcome. Our stay was made even more enjoyable by the breakfast included, which offered a better than average variety of food.

There was nothing that we found lacking in our experience at this hotel.

As youngsters, we absolutely loved the gospel instrumental music and beautiful décor. The location was perfect with shops, theater, and restaurants nearby. The staff was amazing, helpful, and friendly. The continental breakfast was delicious and the staff was pleasant. The entire facility was stunning and spotlessly clean. Our anniversary spent there was truly memorable.

Felt incredibly fortunate to have stumbled upon this gem, no complaints whatsoever.

We had a fantastic stay! The hotel was beautiful, clean, and smelled amazing. The breakfast was great and the staff was friendly. The pool was amazing, and we enjoyed using the gym. The balcony of our room was wonderful, and we loved the common areas and the library. The location was great, with a few shops and a restaurant within walking distance. The little snack store was convenient and had a variety of options. we were very comfortable and had a wonderful experience.

Nothing, all great.

Spacious rooms with beautiful quilts and plenty of pillows. Delicious food at the onsite restaurant and a good continental breakfast. Helpful staff and a clean environment. Convenient parking and a variety of activities for kids. a delightful stay.

The complimentary cookies and popcorn were a great touch, and the 24/7 coffee and water were helpful. The location was perfect, with shopping, dining, and entertainment all within walking distance. We also enjoyed the pool and the cozy décor in the lobby.

The mattress in our room was too soft for our liking, and there was limited counter space in the bathroom. Parking was also a bit of a hassle, as we had to park farther away from the entrance.