The peaceful atmosphere and excellent staff make for a comfortable stay. The breakfast spread is impressive, and the new pool and hot tub are a hit. Some room issues noted, but overall a pleasant experience. Great location for exploring the town.

Comfortable beds, friendly staff, and delicious breakfast at Blue Gate Garden Inn. Convenient location for exploring Shipshewana. Family-friendly atmosphere with a festive holiday decor. A great spot to return for a relaxing stay.

Great Location and Clean Rooms

The hotel's location near the Performing Arts Center was convenient, and the room was mostly clean providing a comfortable stay overall. However, improvements could be made regarding the cleanliness of the air conditioning filters and outdated amenities such as the sofa bed and loose wall outlets.

Oh my goodness, the breakfast at this place is to die for! 🥞 so many options, especially the made-to-order omelets - just delicious! the rooms were comfy, but the staff lacked warmth. 🥺

Relaxed, clean, perfect getaway at Blue Gate Garden Inn. Peaceful room, excellent breakfast spread. Top-notch staff, truly outstanding. Enjoyed the amenities, cozy bed, and delightful spritz cookies. A wonderful escape!

Suite only had 4 towels.

I always return for the excellent service. The staff kindly assisted serving my elderly parents. The amenities like Wi-Fi, 24-hour reception, and indoor pool suit me perfectly. I appreciate the convenience for my city trips.

Blue Gate was spotlessly clean with comfy bedding, ample towels, and quality amenities. Fast check-in and out, plus abundant breakfast options like delicious egg casserole and coffee.

No available plastic utensils.

LOVED the homemade breakfast omelettes! Staff were helpful. The indoor pool was better than expected. Definitely going back!

I was visiting for a weekend getaway and stayed for two nights. The cleanliness of the room and bathroom was exceptional, and I had a great night's sleep. The temperature control was easy to adjust, and the common areas like the elevator and hallways were impeccably clean. I appreciated the attention to detail, from the dust-free furniture to the smudge-free windows and mirrors. The pizza and ice cream parlor saved the day when everything else was closed for dinner on a Sunday. The waffle bowl and pizza were delicious, and the variety of indoor and outdoor seating options made it a wonderful place to relax. The free breakfast had a fantastic selection and the staff was friendly and helpful. a perfect 10 experience!

Couldn't recommend this hotel more!

Beautiful property, big and clean rooms, friendly and helpful staff, walkable to theatre, no traffic jams, delicious food options.

The Blue Gate Restaurant and Theatre, just a mile north of the Garden Inn, was a delightful experience for the whole family. The live performances and captivating shows were a hit with the kids, and the food was simply scrumptious. We had a blast playing at the teatherball court, always a ton of fun, and the charming Amish-style breakfast room added a unique cultural touch to our mornings.

My wife says that a children's play area within the hotel premises would have been a great addition for families with kids.

The breakfast at the Blue Gate Garden Inn was a highlight, with a variety of options and friendly staff. The rooms were clean and comfortable, and the location was convenient for exploring the Amish area. Despite some maintenance issues, the overall stay was enjoyable, especially the easy access to the nearby theater for a concert.

This isn't my first or last visit to the Blue Gate. The amenities and staff are exceptional. The breakfast is amazing, with gluten-free options and delicious omelettes. The sheets and bedding smelled wonderful. The cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and fire pit were all highlights. The lobby was welcoming and the location is great for shopping. The clean, well-stocked room had comfortable beds and a dividing door. We even enjoyed a beautiful snowfall. A great place to stay!

Do recommend this hotel.

had a lovely stay in shipshewana, exceeded expectations. cozy lobby, friendly staff, and amazing free breakfast with great food and efficient service. enjoyed the fire pit and the kids loved the ice cream shop. will definitely be back again. 💯

Pool area can get crowded with kids.

I recently stayed at a 4-star hotel here, and I must say, it was a fantastic experience. The location was perfect, as it was conveniently close to a few local events that were on the town's website. The public areas were well-maintained and had a beautiful terrace with garden furniture, which provided a tranquil spot to relax. The hotel amenities were top-notch, with features like an indoor swimming pool, jacuzzi, and a well-equipped fitness center. The staff was friendly and accommodating, providing excellent service throughout my stay. The room itself was clean, comfortable, and had all the necessary amenities like a flat-screen TV and air conditioning. I was very impressed with the level of comfort and quality services offered at this hotel.

I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a luxurious and comfortable stay.